A case study in which a returning officer, whose staff face violent threats from goons during a contested election, must decide whether devotion to duty should be pursued at the cost of the staff's personal safety.
Ashi Sharma, AIR 12, 2024
Free and fair elections are a part of the basic structure of the constitution and the cornerstone for a democracy. but issues like electoral malpractices continue to put a damper on them
Issues 1. rampant criminalisation of politics and politicisation of criminals (eg) In 17th LS 43% MPs -> criminals 2. threat to personal safety of officers in line of duty 3. use of violence to create fear psychosis in the minds of administration and people 4. casteism and communalism being instigated using hate speech undermining Sarva dharma Sambhava in society 5. undermining of democratic values like equality, Justice, fairness, and secularism. 6. Violation of formula of ends as politics is being used as means to only advance electoral gains not public welfare 7. this amounts to the social sin of politics without principle
Devotion to duty at the cost of personal safety of staff arguments in favour 1. upholds the categorical imperative by doing our duty 2. ensures adherence to rules, laws, regulations 3. it ensures greater good of the electorate by detering hate speech and electoral malpractices
arguments against 1. human life is sacrosanct 2. it amounts to bad leadership as officer in charge is also responsible for the wellbeing of staff. 3. it would cause guilt, moral discomfort and cognitive dissonance
Therefore to perform duty knowing that it would lead to endangering life of staff does not pass the test of ethicality.
Solution 1. First & foremost I would lodge a police complaint against the goons and ensure they are kept in police custody. 2. I would also write to ECI to send across more personnel and Security (CRPF) to ensure I am able to do my duty effectively 3. I would write to the Chief Secretary communicating the seriousness of the situation and urge him to provide all possible assistance 4. I would also reach out to CSOs and media to raise awareness to build up pressure on the candidates 5. I would also press charges against them under RPA 1951
In the long term the solutions involve - political reforms - improving intra party democracy - voter awareness campaigns - decriminalisation of politics.
All steps must be taken to ensure free & fair elections, meanwhile we should also explore One nation one election alternative.