Topper Copies

You have recently joined as the Chief Executive Officer of the Water Supply and Sewerage Board in a metropolitan city of India. Recently, there was an incident where two poor people died while undertaking hazardous cleaning of sewers in a posh neighbourhood, housing top corporate honchos of the city. The preliminary report found that a few residents in the said neighbourhood employed private workers to clean the sewers without the knowledge of the local city administration. A complaint for causing death by negligence has been registered against the concerned residents as well as the private contractor through whom these poor people were employed to carry out the task. The complaint has come as a shock to the residents of the neighbourhood, most of whom never had a brush with the law before. During the investigation, the residents of the neighbourhood complained that the local administration has not been cleaning sewers for a long time, forcing them to hire private workers. You also come to know that there has been a confusion over the maintenance works in the city administration, with no resolution till date. The city administration, as a whole, has also been facing a shortage of funds to build the requisite infrastructure and provide protective gears to carry out the sewage cleaning work. In the meantime, the family members of the deceased have started pressurising the government for compensation and there has also been a media blitzkrieg blaming the apathy of the city administration for the incident and pressure to withdraw the complaints registered against the high profile residents of the neighbourhood. In light of the above situation, answer the following questions: (a) Identify the stakeholders involved in the case along with the associated issues. (b) Evaluate the options that are available to you in the given case. Which of these options will you choose and why? (c) What will be the long-term measures you will take to prevent such an incident from occurring in the future? (Answer in 250 words)

Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023

Case of sewer related deaths have been on the rise and many organizations have tried solving it but to no avail highlighting the significance of this case study.

(a) Stakeholders involved & their issues 1. Poor people who sell their labour to make two ends meet 2. The contractors whose livelihood is also dependent on these people. 3. Residents of the area for whom sewer cleaning is an essential service. 4. Municipal bodies for whom this task is their bread and butter. Moral responsibility on them to get sewers cleaned.

(b) Options available

(1) Take strict action against residents

| Pro | Con | |---|---| | serve as an example | Media will tarnish image of civil administration | | lack of knowledge of law is no excuse to break it | will affect these people adversely |

(2) Compensate victims using money from residents

| Pro | Cons | |---|---| | Justice will be seen to be done | difficult to give a price to human life | | will give little closure to deceased family | difficulty in execution |

(3) Revoke case against the people and serve them warning

| Pro | Cons | |---|---| | Serve as an example | execution challenges | | "win-win" type situation for all | |

A combination of (2) and (3) can be utilised to ensure that justice is not only done but seen to be done. This will ensure that such incidents won't happen in future and closure is given to family of deceased people.

(c) Long term Measures From municipal side 1. Timely cleaning sewers 2. Using CSR from companies in those areas to get safety gears 3. Using technology like "Bandikoot" robots for such work 4. Raise money through municipal bonds

For poor people 1. Train them for other works 2. Ensure their health, food and education needs are met. 3. Rope in civil society to give them adequate training.

Thus, sewer deaths should become a thing of the past in 21st century to ensure Gandhi's talisman of ensuring Sarvodaya through Antyodaya.