3. (a) How should public servants ethically balance stakeholder interests, official obligations and regime values when making administrative decisions, and which of these should be given the most moral weight?
Ashi Sharma, AIR 12, 2024
Public servants often have to walk the tight rope between conflicting demands of stakeholder interests, official obligations and regime values in governance.
Balancing All Three 1. By paying heed to their voice of conscience guiding them towards doing the right thing 2. By staying true to their core values of public service. eg honesty, impartiality, integrity etc. 3. By upholding the rule of law in letter & spirit 4. Seeking advice from experts or seniors - eg if an old destitute widow without a ration card comes seeking help to get access to food subsidy, public servants should uphold her interest + ensure she gets the help she needs.
Maximum Moral Weight All three are important and need to be balanced, but in my opinion stakeholder interest should be prioritised because →
on the other hand,
Regime values: may not always align with democratic values eg regime values of Nazi party promoted anti-semitism.
Official duties: often prescribe the minimum and are not exhaustive in nature; creating possibilities of escapism by officials.
Need of the hour is ethical management to ensure public servants make the right choice in the right situation.