Topper Copies

A case study in which a district collector must decide how to respond to a temple's ban on the entry of young women, which sits at the cost of constitutional morality.

Ashi Sharma, AIR 12, 2024

Indian society is deeply religious and religion influences all facets of our life, but sometimes this happens at the cost of Constitutional morality, as is the case in this case

Administrative Issues 1. possibility of unrest and riots, which may threaten safety of not only the people but also administration 2. difficulties in enforcing laws due to pressure from society and religious leader. 3. managing crowds in the event of an uproar

Ethical Issues 1. Violation of dignity of women 2. perpetuation of the evil mentality of patriarchy 3. rigid resistance to change by temple authorities 4. violation of human rights like right to equality, right against discrimination and right to practice religion. 5. dilution of constitutional morality.

Options Available A. Strictly enforce free entry of women in temple - merits: uphold their rights, gender empowerment, overtime decrease conservatism in society - demerits: social backlash, riots, communalism, will not address deep rooted patriarchy

B. Maintain Status Quo - merits: maintain peace in area, prevent any violence. - demerits: against spirit of constitution, violates categorical imperative to do duty, discrimination against women

C. Set up a broad based committee with concerned stakeholders - merits: assure women of action, forge consensus, prevent violent outbursts - demerits: delay decision making, elite capture is possible, consensus may remain elusive.

Chosen Course of Action So I would go with the third option and set up a committee and start the process to ensure access of rights to women because

1. Indian model of secularism is positive 2. All religious practices are subject to reasonable limitations 3. religion must be able to stand up to the scrutiny of constitutional morality.

I would also ensure that the committee has access to legal counsel and facilitate justice via judicial intervention if need be.

Even in Sabrimala Case, the SC court intervention ensured temple entry for women

Once there is legal clarity, I would ensure women are able to enter the temple by providing security support.

In the long run I would focus on conducting gender sensitisation and constitutional awareness programmes to enable behavioural change in public at large.

"I judge the progress of a society by the way it treats its women". We must ensure gender equality we aspire to be Vikisit Bharat