Topper Copies

A case study in which a compliance officer discovers that a greentech company has violated environmental norms in pursuit of profit, and must decide how to respond.

Ashi Sharma, AIR 12, 2024

Laws often prescribe the bare minimum ethics on the other hand are broad and exhaustive. But what is ethical may not be legal and what is legal may not be ethical. This case study also deals with a similar grey area.

Ethical virtues 1. violation of core corporate value of environmentalism of Greentech companies 2. limited impact of laws, rules and regulations in ensuring ethical behaviour 3. violates formula of the end as environment is being used as an means alone to advance profits.

Ethical Dilemmas 1. adhering to established laws or listening to the voice of conscience. 2. protecting the commercial interests of the company or protecting the environment and people 3. Duty to ensure compliance or showing compassion for the wellbeing of locals.

Available options A. Ignore the issue and maintain status quo. - merits: uphold my duty, protect commercial interest, protect image of company, perfectly legal, no punishment - demerits: environmental degradation, loss of human lives, moral discomfort, guilt, cognitive dissonance

B. Report the issue to relevant authority. - merits: prevent feeling of guilt, uphold morality, protect environment, prevent an ecological/industrial action in the future - demerits: backlash from co-workers, may not listen or take action, we may have to face job insecurity

C. Expose it to Media by blowing the whistle - merits: attract attention, increase pressure to address issue, encourage other companies to rectify their practices - demerits: sensationalisation of issue, media trial, may not lead to tangible solution as issue will soon die out.

Course of Action After evaluating the pros and cons of all possible options, I would go ahead with reporting the findings of the audit to the Board of Directors. This is based on ->

1. ethical capitalism as suggested by Gandhiji 2. doing commerce without morality is a social sin 3. ensure greater good of the greater number in the long run 4. it would uphold the values of justice and honesty 5. In the long run, I would advice to formulate a specialised task force to come up with affordable & sustainable industrial waste management practices 6. For this purpose, I would advice to look into Green bonds and ESG investment Channels 7. I would try to highlight that though such a move has cost implications in the short run, it will yield rich dividends in the form of public trust, goodwill in the long run.

Greening industries is an important part of the long term low emission development plan of India. Corporates must take a lead her.