What steps are required for the constitutionalization of a Commission? Do you think granting constitutional status to the Central Information Commission (CIC) would strengthen the RTI regime in India? Give reasons.
Surabhi Yadav, AIR 14, 2025
Central Information Commission is a Statutory Body established by Act of Parliament.
Steps for Constitutionalisation of a Commission
1. Presentation of the Bill by the Member of the Parliament in LS or RS. (under Art 368) 2. Passed by one House by Special Majority - 2/3rd present & voting + 1/2 of total House. 3. Passed to other House, similar procedure is followed in other House. 4. Bill goes to the President. President has to give assent. 5. New Article is Added and the Commission becomes a Constitutional Body
Current challenges of CIC as Statutory Body
- recommendatory Nature -> Changes are easy to be made in structure eg RTI amendment Act, 2019. - lack powers as Independent Body. - appointments are by the legislature (hamper independence) - Salary etc also determining by Parliament, thus reducing their autonomy
Constitutional Status could strengthen the RTI regime
1. Ensure Independence of the Commission. eg Security of Tenure, Salary charged on Consolidated fund etc. 2. Give them power of Civil Court - ensure better investigation of charges. 3. Have more Independence in pushing for voluntary publication of Details eg Rajasthan Jan soochna Portal. 4. Complement Article 19 -> ensuring more freedoms and Right to know.
Thus a constitutional status may grant better opportunity to CIC to implement RTI. But, need to be followed in letter & spirit & essence of the commission, adhered by the officers -> A/c -> T/p -> Responsiveness