How is the 'vertical' and 'horizontal' devolution of taxes to the states decided? Highlighting the concerns raised by some states regarding the devolution of taxes, suggest corrective measures.
Surabhi Yadav, AIR 14, 2025
The 101st Constitutional Amendment & Inserting Article 279 A - GST Council along with the Finance Commission (Art 324) have ensured the financial viability of our governance structure.
Deciding on the Vertical Devolution of Taxes
1. Finance Commission determine - Based on Centre's Revenue - Based on State's need - eg 15th FC provided for (41% devolution) (2% for new UT of J&K & Ladakh)
-> Also decide grants to local Self govt.
2. State Finance Commission - State -> LSG. 3. G.S.T council Determine share of IGST = CGST + SGST. It is decided by voting 1/3rd centre & 2/3rd state.
Deciding the Horizontal Devolution of Taxes
2. Its also determined by the Finance Commission. Share of various states is split among UP, Bihar, Punjab, Raj, TN, Kerala, other.
Factors into Consideration: Income Distance (45%), Area, Population, Demographic progress; also Taxes (2.5%) for forest & Ecology.
Concerns Raised by some State governments
1. Vertical Imbalance: State feel after GST subsumed - low grants: loss of Revenue. 2. Cess & Surcharge - not part of Devolution eg 14.5% of Revenue of Centre. 3. Vertical Imbalance - States like UP get more but TN gets less from centre despite high contribution eg Remarks like contri ₹10 get ₹2. 4. Population as criteria eg Kerala punished for Investment in Demography. 5. Nature of tied grants - limits flexibility
Ways to Address
1. 16th Finance Commission -> Consultation wider. 2. Cess & Surcharge - part of Division pool 3. GST council for better negotiation. 4. Increase %age of Demographic Progress