1. (b) How does the conscientious public servant sort through competing considerations and determine "the right thing to do?" When it comes to serving the public how does one put one's values into practice? Illustrate with examples.
Ashi Sharma, AIR 12, 2024
Public servants perform complex tasks under demanding situations with competing considerations, ethical knowledge helps them determine what is right to do.
Doing the right thing 1. public servants ensure they adhere to constitutional & legal values & provisions 2. They objectively assess the merits of the situation through: - cost benefit analysis - utilitarianism: (greater good of greater number) 3. they ensure their decisions ensure justice for the marginalised & vulnerable (eg elderly, disabled etc) as per care ethics 4. they strive to uphold values as per virtue ethics.
Putting Values into Practice 1. lead by example by showing transformational leadership. - eg TN Seshan displayed impartiality & non partisanship in ensuring free & fair elections as CEC. 2. upholding the values in daily practice & business - eg an officer valuing professionalism would ensure she is punctual at work. 3. displaying integrity and staying true to one's values even in the face of adversity. - eg Satyendranath Dubey regarded honesty as a virtue and exposed corruption at NHAI even at the cost of personal safety. 4. motivating others to follow shared values. - eg Sam Manickshaw's patriotism and devotion to duty inspired countless others in the army
Ensuring translation of values into actions needs robust ethical management; Mission Karamyogi is a step in the right direction.