Topper Copies

"The judiciary has functioned as an institutional corrective, redefining and refining the contours of the Governor's office to prevent its misuse and uphold constitutional principles." Discuss this statement with the help of relevant case laws.

Surabhi Yadav, AIR 14, 2025

Article 153 provides for the office of governor in every state. S/He acts as the mediator between the Centre & the State and thus upholds the Federalism Spirit as Co-operative System.

However, in Recent days, confrontations have led to the

Judiciary Function as Institutional

1. Corrective - Defining powers of governor to call for state emergency. (Art 356) - eg upheld the Manipur emergency; eg Uttrakhand HC struck down emergency in 2016 - Ramabrian Case - SC held that mere suspicion of horsetrading cannot be considered ground for Art 356 or govt dismissal. 2. Redefining and Refining the Contours - Governor's discretion on Bills. SC in State of Tamil Nadu v/s BN Rai, 2025 have defined the timeline for passage of the Bills: 1 month for governor, 3 months for President-assent, 1 month for re-referred bill. - Other matters like Vice-chancellor appointment are still subjudice. - Supreme Court in S.R. Bommai Case, 1994 has also ensured limits on powers of governors.

Challenges -> Judicial overreach -> Not the constitutional Mandate; Judiciary & Executive confrontations

But, overall these features have helped uphold Constitutional Principles

1. Governor as only Representative Head 2. Democratic Mandate upheld: legislature over Executive.

Further, recommendations of Sarkaria, Punchhi and Rajmannar Commission have helped strengthen the office of governor.