Topper Copies

You are the District Magistrate of a district, which is the hub of coaching centres for engineering as well as medical entrance exams. Recently, around 5 students have committed suicide owing to academic and social pressure. Students in the age group 15-18 years from across the country come to the district with the dream of getting admission into prestigious institutions like the IITs and AIIMS. However, the coaching institutes are business-minded and want to have toppers from their institute so that they can attract more students. They create a lot of pressure on students to perform, with differential treatment like forming different category of batches depending on students' performance. These students live as Paying Guests and in hostels away from their families and many cannot tackle the huge burden of competition and the associated mental stress. The recent spate of suicide by 5 students has been highlighted by the national media and you have been asked by the Chief Minister to present a report of the situation and take steps on the matter. The Chief Minister has also asked you to keep the matter away from limelight so that the coaching centres continue with their business and generate revenue for themselves as well as the state. Upon investigation, you find out that 2-3 of the most famous coaching institutions are run by political leaders of the ruling party. They are involved in false advertisements in order to lure students. They also create undue pressure on the students to perform. Also, there is an emerging black market for performance enhancing drugs, which have become common among the students. Given the situation: (a) Highlight the stakeholders involved and discuss the associated ethical issues in the given case. (b) Given the situation, what will be your course of action? (c) Discussing the various reasons for increased cases of suicides among students, suggest measures to address the issue in the long-run. (Answer in 250 words)

Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023

Rising suicide cases among students due to performance pressure has become a harsh reality and it is important to solve this before it turns into a disaster.

(a) Stakeholders involved

[diagram: a timeline of stakeholders - Parents, Students, PG owners, Drug producers, workers & teachers of coaching, Coaching mafias, Politicians - with "society as a whole" spanning underneath as an arrow]

Associated Ethical issues in the given case- 1. Students' wish to achieve success at the cost of mental peace and physical well being 2. Rising aspirations of parents to ensure their kids do nothing but the best. 3. Coaching institutes' pursuit of profit converting them into a "money making machine" 4. PG owners' will to extract maximum out of students, at the cost of their mental well being. 5. Politicians' nexus with coaching mafias who will thwart every attempt to solving this issue. 6. Industry of the performance enhancing drug market who are showing utter disregard to students' health. 7. Society at large having high regards for the exceptional and trying to judge every child from a single yardstick.

All the above ethical issues lead to children preferring dying over performing.

(b) Course of action 2 priorities -> (A) mental stability of kids -> capitalism should be compassionate - its okay to make profit, but not out of one's life.

(A) 1. Make groups of kids in a society to ensure counselling 2. Coaching centres can be mandated to have a psychologist at their institute 3. Teachers can be made to be more empathetic. Ex- train teachers to not harass a child who scores low 4. Intermix batches to ensure good and okay students collaborate and uplift each other 5. Sports facility in the area to ensure physical well being -> mental satiation. 6. Counselling of parents to ensure they don't put too much pressure on child.

(B) 1. Cap fees taken by coaching 2. Ensure CSR activities are done by them by coaching poor kids. 3. Involve politicians in the talk and explain to them the adverse effect of this phenomenon. 4. Expand online coachings, so that kids can study while being there with parents.

(c) Reasons for suicides 1. Kids have become a means to satisfy parents' aspirations 2. Society devalues those who aren't able to achieve in life. 3. Professors in coaching mock weak students. 4. Kids feel if they don't achieve, they will have to face dire consequences 5. Fees spent on education acts as moral pressure on them.

Measures in long term 1. Education shouldn't become an industry -> Remove advertisements with false stories 2. Engage elderly of that area to engage with children in distress 3. Parks, Gyms for kids so that they have a life apart from this 4. Vocational courses for those who aren't able to perform

Keeping in mind Kant's view, kids shouldn't be treated as means to an end, but an end in themselves.