Topper Copies

The basic structure doctrine acts as a constitutional compass in balancing Parliament's legislative authority and constitutional supremacy. Comment.

Surabhi Yadav, AIR 14, 2025

Basic Structure doctrine was 1st discussed in I.C. Golaknath Case but it was finally consolidated in Keshavananda Bharti Case, 1973

Basic Structure Doctrine act as Constitutional Compass -> Upholded by the Judiciary -> judiciary acts as guardian of the Constitution -> ensure people's trust in the constitution, give relative freedom to the parliament

It has Balanced Parliament's legislative Authority

1. Wide Interpretation of Art 368 Amending power of Parliament - can amend any part even FR. 2. Overturned earlier judicial cases like Golaknath Case - FR can't be amended 3. Gave scope of DPSP implementation to the Parliament. Art 39(b)(c) > Act 14,19,31 4. Ensure the Welfare Motive of the state

It has also upheld the Constitutional Supremacy

1. Judicial cases to define the Basic Structure case wise -> ensured comprehensive definition. 2. Upheld Federalism, Secularism, Separation of Powers as the Basic Features. 3. The essence of Constitution is Preamble can't be amended. 4. Preserved the Rights of the people eg Freedom of speech and Expression Basic feature (Indian Express case)

However, the Basic Structure Doctrine has some

Ways to Address

1. Codification eg Germany's Basic Law. 2. Refer to Higher Bench of SC. 3. Codification by Amendments in Constitution by Parliament.