Topper Copies

You are a young IAS officer and have recently joined as a Sub-Divisional Magistrate in a district, which has been declared 'open defecation free'. However, you get information that some villages in your sub-division are still continuing the practice of open defecation out of habit despite availability of toilets. Your colleagues in the district administration confirm that the information is true. You call the village headmen of these villages and tell them to persuade their respective villagers to stop open defecation. But, they express their unwillingness and inability to fully stop this practice, as in some cases they themselves consider it healthy to defecate in the open. You discuss this matter with the District Magistrate who forbids you from taking any official action, as this may cause the 'open defecation free' status given to the district to be withdrawn. As a young and dynamic officer, answer the following: (a) Why do people continue to practice open defecation even when they have access to toilets? (b) What are the options available to you as the Sub-Divisional Magistrate in this case? Highlight the merits and demerits of each option. (c) What will be your course of action? (Answer in 250 words)

Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023

The given case study is a common concern which has been making headlines after "open defecation free" status was prioritized by govt.

(a) Reasons for continued practice 1. Difficult to bring attitudinal change quickly. 2. Unaware about potential harms of this practice 3. Religious beliefs - Temple and toilet can't be used in one premise. 4. Lack of Persuasion Techniques used by the govt. 5. No crises of Conscience -as it is absolutely normal for them. 6. Physical limitations might be there like lack of access to water. 7. Stubborn attitude of people to do what has been prohibited.

(b) Options available

(1) Do nothing about it

| Pros | Cons | |---|---| | ODF status retained | not good for society | | | Crises of conscience for me |

(2) Take official action and penalise those going for open defecation

| Pros | Cons | |---|---| | fear of law will prevent open defecation | ODF status under threat | | | against boss's direction (may lead to tiff in workspace) |

(3) Take informal action and persuade people to not do this practice.

| Pros | Cons | |---|---| | benefit to society | Implementational challenge without official help. | | ODF status retained | | | DM can also help me (not going against his/her wishes) | |

(c) Course of action It would be right to take the 3rd action as follows- 1. Form an informal team of volunteers, who will act as persuaders and surveillance keepers 2. Train them to woo people away from defecating in the open as it is against their health 3. Utilize AASHA workers to educate women by going door-to-door to not allow their family members from defecating in open. 4. Use persuasion techniques (a) Messenger- Employ religious leaders to deliver the message (ensure its wide use) (b) Simple message- "Abse Darwaza Band" [used by Vidya Balan] 5. Social Influence by open theatre movies highlighting how unhygienic this practice it. 6. Strict surveillance of frequently used open places specially in morning 7. Communicate with villagers who are adamant; win their hearts and minds and make them obey.

Thus, "Naya Bharat" should remain ODF if it has to fulfill its claims of being a world leader.