You are a senior engineer working for S & P Constructions, a prominent government contractor. You are working at a construction site building a nuclear reactor facility. Along with other responsibilities at the site, you were also the safety in charge. One day as you did your weekly safety audit, you noticed that the welders had not followed procedures and used the wrong materials in some sections. The situation was hazardous since some defective welds appeared on the water pipes carrying coolant to the reactor core. The rupture of the pipes could cause disaster if safety backups failed simultaneously. You called a meeting of the welding supervisors to instruct them to rectify the faulty weldings. But even after two weeks, the welds were not fixed, and when asked, the supervisors said they had instructions from the superiors to go ahead with the way it is. You were shocked at this compromise of safety. You travelled to the HQ to discuss this with the senior management. Instead of taking corrective action, the senior management transferred you to a different site and warned you about discussing the safety practices of the nuclear site. You needed the job, so you returned to your new workplace quietly. After five years, the nuclear reactor was in the news for pipe bursts, killing ten engineers and due to the fallout, the neighbouring villages had to be evacuated. You could see your fears coming true. The nuclear facility was shut down, and an inquiry was instituted. You were also summoned for questioning as you handled safety during the construction. You were in a dilemma; tell the truth of safety compromise or hide it and keep the job. Further, your conscience was troubling you that you could have done something five years back instead of quickly taking the transfer. 1. What are the issues involved in the above case? 2. What options do you have in the above dilemma? 3. After evaluating the options, identify which option you would choose. 4. Do you think whistle-blowing could have been a good option five years back?
Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023
The cases of bending under seniors pressure have heightened the cases of ethical dilemmas in jobs.
1) Issues involved (a) Should you speak the truth and risk losing the job (b) Should you raise alarm against the superiors who didnt adhere to your advice then (c) Was it correct on your part to have left the situation (d) how to manage the crises of conscience that led to the recent mayhem
2) Options available
(a) speak the truth | Merits | Dements | |---|---| | Reduce crises of conscience | will lose job | | Lead to effective action against the perpetrators | senior too will lose job |
(b) Keep mum | Merits | Dements | |---|---| | Job restored | crises of conscience | | good rapport with senior | who will be responsible for the mayhem - your conscience will pinch you forever |
(c) Listen to your conscience, speak up against everyone | Merits | Dements | |---|---| | good for your conscience | lose your job and seniors rapport | | perpetrators will get punished | | | closure to the village people who lost their homes & families of engineer | |
3) Course of action (c) option should be taken to ensure that justice is given to all stakeholders involved viz - people of village - families of engineers who lost life - self conscience
4) Whistle blowing Whistle blowing could have been the best option and would have prevented the recent mayhem. A file noting highlighting the ineffectiveness of the system would have saved the lifes of the engineer and one would have not lost to ones conscience. It will remain a lifelong pain as to why one didnt speak up then and ensured Nishkam Karma.