What conflicts does a public official face between competing interests and between competing sources of authority, and what makes inner courage relevant in resolving them?
Ashi Sharma, AIR 12, 2024
Decision making is the essence of administration, but this is a highly complex process which often deals with conflicts namely among interests and sources of authority.
| Conflict among Interests | Conflict among Sources of authorities | |---|---| | occurs when personal interest overlaps with official duty. (eg) a public official may face a conflict of interest if his family member applies for a government tender for which the said officer is the granting authority | Occurs when one is confused between obeying the orders of 2 or more equally competant authorities. (eg) a public official (IAS) may face a conflict when both centre & state governments give her mutually conflicting directives | | It is possible to avoid this conflict by recusing oneself from the situation | recusal is not an option in this situation as orders are by competant authorities. | | this happens at a personal level | this can happen at a personal or departmental level | | to deal with this officials need to uphold values of honesty & integrity | to deal with this officers need courage and impartiality |
Public officials must be trained to use their discretion wisely and ethically to solve such conflicts.
Complexity and challenges of government are daunting and confusing, this is often used by administrators as an excuse for inaction and inertia.
governance challenges - uncertainities: transfers, suspension, change in incumbency, global events like war, pandemic - ambiguities: lack of legal clarity and loopholes.
Relevance of inner courage While there are legal and constitutional safeguards to protect civil servants, inner courage helps them to ->
1. to maintain their integrity in problematic situations (eg) IAS officer Ashok Khemka's Commitment despite multiple transfers 2. to act in an impartial and neutral manner (eg) former CEC TN Seshan 3. to be able to take tough decisions and exercise one's authority (eg) taking action against staff for misconduct 4. to be able to stay calm and composed even in the face of crisis (eg) riots, natural disasters 5. to be able to raise their voice against administrative malpractices (eg) Satyendra Jain exposed irregularities in NHAI 6. to be able to provide unbiased and non partisan feedback on performance of policies 7. to be able to address the needs and concerns of weak & vulnerable sections 8. to be able to face societal backlash for unpopular yet necessary progressive reforms 9. to be able to manage political pressures.
Inner Courage is thus like a moral powerhouse for civil servants empowering them to fulfil their duty fearlessly.