Social justice is not charity, it is structural rebalancing.
Surabhi Yadav, AIR 14, 2025
Social Justice is not charity, it is structural Rebalancing
Two children born together on 3rd July 2000 at the same time 10:00 pm in the night. One was born in Medanta hospital, Delhi while the other's family couldn't even afford to go to the government hospital. The child is born at home aided by a Dai, in Chattisgarh village. They both grew up, one went to DPS, RK Puram, while the other went to the government school located 10km away from home. One grew deprived while the other had access to education and resources.
Now, if the government intervene through schemes like PM Kaushal - to skill, providing free education through RTE or provide employement under MGNREGA - to the child born in Chattisgarh, using the tax collected from the father of the child in Delhi. Will that be considered a charity or a social restructuring?
Before answering the question, let's understand few terms:-
Social justice means making the society more inclusive. It means that haves and have nots have equal resource in the Society. It aims to ensure that rich or poor, girl or boy, man or women, disabled or not, LGBTQIA+ or not, everyone have equal access and standing in Society without discrimination.
Charity, on the other hand would mean giving resources for free without having anything in return. Its often understood as sign of weakness.
Thus, the topic presents the view that Social justice often led by Welfarist government is rebalancing the society. Social justice would ensure greater good by ensuring harmony, cohesion and equity through structurally rebalancing different actors in the nation or world at large.
This essay however also explores, when methods and means of Social Justice becomes a tools of charity and undermine the larger good.
Let's understand how the social justice is ensured in the society. It is largely a government led idea. Our Preamble:- the Introduction talks about Justice - social, economical & political, thus becomes obligatory for the government to ensure justice in the society.
Government often do this by ensuring equity in the society, by equal distribution of resources. It was done immediately after Independence through schemes like Land Reforms, cancelling of Privy Purse by 26th CAA.
Government ensure this further by providing access to opportunities through Ideas like Affirmative actions or building up Inclusive Infrastructure as in new Parliament Buildings for the PwDs.
But why then social justice is considered a charity? Its because the government do not expect any direct services from the beneficiaries. The beneficiaries are seen as enjoying a life without hard work. Schemes like DBT, PDS distribution or Farm loan waivers have been subject to criticism that they even create laxating attitude and Farmers deliberately do not pay loans, because they know they'll get waivers.
Its also considered a charity because, social beneficiaries do not pay taxes while the upper middle class and rich do. These taxes are often connoted as money set aside for charity of poor.
However, the situation is not that clean, and It should be seen through a larger prism. It should be seen, how social Justice in India has aided India to become 4th largest economy, while the countries like Pakistan, got Independence on same day, crippled today. Or a country like Sudan, Somalia have lacked far behind, and struggle for daily survival.
Let's understand how Social Justice is the Structural Rebalancing.
Social Justice of Today is the compensation for the years of historical Injustice to the marginalised community. Whether we talk about Caste atrocities where still 90% of the manual scavengers belong to SC community or the benefits of Industrial Revolution by the west and recent demands of Loss and Damage by global South to effectively adapt to climate change.
Further, Rousseau in his book Discourse on Origin of Inequality discussed how the inequality is a social construct. Man is born free yet everywhere in chains, highlights how a w/man is caged by the social construct. A woman is expected to raise a family, while a man expected to earn for the family, both equally harmful principle.
Thus it becomes important that Social Justice through an agency restore that balance like the two wings of an aeroplane.
Moreover, it also ensures cohesion and harmony in the society. If there is a community marked by stark economic differences, like the Bandra in South and Dharavi slum to the north, it creates feeling of Relative Deprevation. It becomes the reason for social anxiety, disturbances and violence. Social Inequality often leads to viscious cycles of Crimes and Poverty.
Further, its even important to balance two economists both with their advantage and challenges. Adam Smith's Capitalism in Wealth of Nations and Karl Marx's Idea of Socialism in Das Capital. Social Justice in country like India truly encapsulates that. While companies like Adani's, Reliance have become global giants and mark peak of capitalism, efforts like reducing extreme poverty from 11% to 2.3% as noticed by World Bank shows Idea of Rebalancing.
Its also important because these people moved out of poverty will be the consumers of the numerous products by 100+ unicorns setup in India. A producer is only successful when they have an efficient consumer base. Wars have been fought for this like the British colonising India for a good Market of its Industry goods.
However, there are challenges to ensuring Structural Rebalancing through Social Justice. Highly manifested in the form of corruption. Rajiv Gandhi noticed that out of ₹1 sent for the welfare only ₹0.1 reaches the end beneficiary. Or when Schemes are not targeted or backed by comprehensive data, like the lack of Caste Census has raised question on effectiveness of Affirmative Actions.
Certain vulnerable groups remain unheard, due to lack of collective bargaining or lack of social acceptance; like demands by LGBTQIA+ to legalise their marriages remain unaddressed.
However, these challenges could be addressed through comprehensive data analysis, enhanced political will, aid by Bureaucracy in implementation and strong Independent Judiciary through suo moto cases like Vishakha v. State of Rajasthan restored the working space balance.
Despite these measures, It can sometimes by noticed that Social Justice is a charity. It becomes a charity when government distribute freebies like free electricity, bike, fridge etc, without backing it with any outcome analysis in lines of people.
It becomes a charity when it undermines human dignity of the beneficiary. When politicians distribute liquor to get votes or give ₹500/₹1000 for each vote, it undermines human value. Women may face abuse and men be denied of real social justice that could have happened.
However, there have been legal measures like Disqualification under RPA, 1951 or Social media campaigns, how these are small/short term benefits and may not lead to Social Justice.
Thus, government through its welfare scheme benefits all - socially disadvantaged and Advantaged (Roads, SEZs, GIFT city etc) and it shouldn't be seen as a charity for the boy born in Chattisgarh village. But Rebalancing and Bridging the divide between Delhi and Chattisgarh.