Though the antecedents of the Indian Constitution can be traced to a series of British colonial legislation and other constitutions of the world, in spirit and practice it has been completely Indian. Discuss.
Surabhi Yadav, AIR 14, 2025
Dr B.R. Ambedkar was often criticised that ours is a borrowed Constitution and there is no Indianness to it. To which Ambedkar replied - "Other constitutions have stood the test of time. There's no harm in having the fundamentals of it. We just need to modify it to our needs." Such is the essence of our constitution. Various aspects in which our constitution is modified to our needs -
Legislature
- Borrowed from British but - In India PM can be a part of any House. Britain - only lower House - Britain - sovereignty of Parliament India - sovereignty of constitution. - Britain - monarchial India - completely ended monarchy & established a republic. - Britain - only member of Parliament a minister. India - even without being member, minister for max 6 months, to give better opportunities to leaders.
Fundamental Rights
- Though borrowed from USA but differences. - USA - Right to keep arms India - No right to keep arms. Police and other systems provided for the protection of common people. State guaranteed.
DPSP
- Borrowed from Ireland. - But in India great emphasis on principles of DPSP. Even in Minerva Mills case - balance b/w DPSP & FR Ireland - limited in use.
Judiciary
- Borrowed from USA - But Indian Judiciary is an integral system, unlike USA which has Federal Court for each state with their own laws. - It helps maintain uniformity in law & order in the entire nation.
Thus, various organs and antecedents of Indian Constitution, though borrowed from various other institutions, they have been modified, based on extensive debates in Constituent Assembly for almost 3 years. These modifications have also stood the test of time as we completed 75 yrs of our Independence this year in a healthy Democracy.