Topper Copies

You work as an investment banker with one of the country's biggest private banks. You independently handled a team of 15 junior bankers and reported directly to the Head Investment Banking Division. You also networked with individuals with a high net worth in assets and income as part of your job. The purpose of networking was to persuade them to have their income and assets managed by your bank. Over the years, you had brought in a lot of clients for the bank, and you managed assets and accounts for a few big clients. You managed a client with a very sizeable business account, and he frequently received remittances from offshore accounts of his company. In the last six months, you could notice a considerable number of forex transactions had happened in his account. And the money was further moved around to smaller locations within the country. When you tracked the money movement, you noticed that funds were transferred to areas where the client had no business dealings. Government regulations required the bank to report a large inflow of forex funds and client details. You forwarded the details to your Head, who forwarded it to the relevant authorities. When the transactions continued unabated, you got suspicious. On scrutiny, you discovered that the client had dealings with organisations banned by the government for funding anti-national activities. You shared the same information with your Head and requested him to report to the authorities. He said he would look into it. But he didn't. After a few weeks, you raised the matter again, and this time, he curtly told you that the regulations stipulate that account information had to be furnished, which the bank did. It was up to the authorities to scrutinise and take action. The bank was not at fault as it was complying with the law. Further, the Head told you the client was good business for the bank. You were concerned about what to do next as you knew the client was good business, but he was up to no good. 1. What are the issues involved in the case? 2. What are the options available to you? 3. Select your course of action after analysing all the options 4. Do you think breaching client confidentiality and trust can be justified in the above case?

Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023

The cases involving private interest vs public good have become a new normal in the modern world, as highlighted in this case study too.

(1) Issues involved (a) Boss isnt doing his duty of raising alarm against the client. (b) Should the client be left unabated just because he gives good business? (Ethics vs Economics) (c) Why are the authorities above not taking action? (d) Can client confidentiality be breached to secure public interest (e) The case can have graver social implications for society

(2) Options available

(a) To do nothing | Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | Boss remains happy | Crises of conscience | | client business keeps coming in | Threat to National security |

(b) To directly speak to the client | Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | Direct confrontation | Threat to ones life | | Maybe the doubts were wrong and someone else was using his account | May lead to client siphoning off to other bank and carrying out his trade from other place |

(c) Speak to authorities above | Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | No crises of conscience | Circumvent authority of boss | | In line with National security and public interest | lead to loss of customer business to bank |

(3) Course of action Thus analysing the above actions, it would be wise to go with (c) option to ensure action is taken against the client It would be in line with utilitarian and common good principle and can actually prevent a serious disaster from happening.

(4) Breaching client confidentiality Breaching client confidentiality and trust is justified here as bankers are eyes of the public and they should report any nefarious activities.

Saving life from terrorist activities is a much bigger aim than breach of confidentiality.

Thus, one should go by the Greek saying "let End rule the world, but not through me" to ensure that peoples life isnt threatened and virtuosity is upheld.