Topper Copies

What should guide a public official's choice between the traditional and care ethics approaches to a decision, and what are the components of quality in public service delivery?

Ashi Sharma, AIR 12, 2024

Ethics is knowing the difference between what you have the right to do and what is right to do; both traditional and care ethics guide public officials in this regard.

Approach in ethical decision making The choice of approach should be guided by ->

1. contextual needs of the situation 2. concerns, needs, aspirations of the stakeholders involved 3. legal obligations under the Constitution, laws, rules regulations.

Traditional Ethics Approach This approach will be more suitable when we need to uphold our duty and ensure rule of law.

(eg) a public servant being offered a bribe should decline and report such activity in line with her categorical imperative.

Care Ethics approach More appropriate when dealing with the special and unique needs of weak & vulnerable sections of the population. It would help in increasing sensitivity and empathy in public officials and ensure inclusive development (leaving no one behind)

(eg) Delhi government offers home based education programmes for specially abled children.

We thus must invest in ethical training of public officials to ensure they use their wisdom & discretion wisely in deciding which approach is appropriate in which situation.

"Quality" in service delivery is concerned with the satisfaction of consumers. Higher the satisfaction of consumers post service delivery better is the quality.

Components of Service Quality 1. Reliability: ensures consistency in service delivery without arbitrariness 2. Assurance: means a guarantee of service delivery by service provider 3. Transparency: ensures openness regarding service standards, grievance redressal mechanisms, processes etc. 4. Empathy: ensures sensitivity on the part of officials towards the needs and problems of people 5. Responsiveness: ensures proactiveness of officials in service delivery, grievance redressal, clarification of queries.

Ways to ensure total quality Efficiency - identifying gaps and loopholes - building capability of both officials and departments - encouraging a culture of continuous improvement

Economy - leveraging technology to decrease leakages (eg) DBT, digital tracking - collective scrutiny through social audits

Effectiveness - code of ethics & conduct for officials - role clarity & goal clarity via citizen charters - performance appraisals based on consumer feedback

Improving public service quality will not only enhance (eg) citizen centricity and professionalism but will also help us achieve goal of Vikshit Bharat.