Highlight the key points of convergence and divergence between the judicial systems of India and USA.
Surabhi Yadav, AIR 14, 2025
Constitutional Makers consulted multiple constitution (over 50) to ensure a robust constitution - 75 yrs and still standing - for India, where we adopted multiple provisions of our judiciary from USA.
Convergence
| Basis | India | USA | |---|---|---| | Independence | Judicial Supremacy | can check on legislature means | | Judicial Review | Basic Structure (Indira Gandhi v Raj Narain) | Important feature. | | Territorial extent | Whole India | Whole USA | | Hierarchy | SC, HC, Local Courts | Federal Courts & State Courts |
Divergence
| Basis | India | USA | |---|---|---| | Laws | SC can try all laws - Centre or State laws | SC can try only Federal laws - State courts try State laws. | | Hierarchy | see diagram below | No Hierarchy. SC and HCs are Independent of each other. | | Judges Election | by Judiciary itself (2nd & 3rd Judges case) | By committee of Judiciary + Executive. | | Tenure of Judges | SC - till 65 yrs, HC - till 62 yrs | lifetime | | Removal of Judges | Impeachment on grounds of proved Misbehaviour or Incapacity. | Impeachment by the Senate & House of People. |
Thus, Judicial System of USA & India share many common parameters.