Topper Copies

Highlight the key points of convergence and divergence between the judicial systems of India and USA.

Surabhi Yadav, AIR 14, 2025

Constitutional Makers consulted multiple constitution (over 50) to ensure a robust constitution - 75 yrs and still standing - for India, where we adopted multiple provisions of our judiciary from USA.

Convergence

| Basis | India | USA | |---|---|---| | Independence | Judicial Supremacy | can check on legislature means | | Judicial Review | Basic Structure (Indira Gandhi v Raj Narain) | Important feature. | | Territorial extent | Whole India | Whole USA | | Hierarchy | SC, HC, Local Courts | Federal Courts & State Courts |

Divergence

| Basis | India | USA | |---|---|---| | Laws | SC can try all laws - Centre or State laws | SC can try only Federal laws - State courts try State laws. | | Hierarchy | see diagram below | No Hierarchy. SC and HCs are Independent of each other. | | Judges Election | by Judiciary itself (2nd & 3rd Judges case) | By committee of Judiciary + Executive. | | Tenure of Judges | SC - till 65 yrs, HC - till 62 yrs | lifetime | | Removal of Judges | Impeachment on grounds of proved Misbehaviour or Incapacity. | Impeachment by the Senate & House of People. |

Thus, Judicial System of USA & India share many common parameters.