Why are State Legislative Assemblies involved in the election of the President but excluded from the process of impeachment?
Surabhi Yadav, AIR 14, 2025
Article 52 provides that there shall be a President of India, who shall be the 1st citizen and Republic Head of India.
Reason for Including MLAs of State legislative Assembly in election of President
1. President is nominal head so should be Representative. 2. Ensure Neutrality - Political of the President eg Zakir Hussain. 3. Ensure Majority of People < Regional National have their say. 4. Uphold Federalism principle.
Reason for excluding MLAs from Impeachment - 2/3rd Majority of all MPs
1. Constitutional Makers thought removal should be smooth process. 2. Including State legislative Assembly might be a cumbersome process. 3. Judicial Oversight becomes important