In the Lok Sabha and the Vidhan Sabhas, the Speaker has vast powers and extensive functions. Elaborating on it, highlight the grounds on which the Office of the Speaker has been criticised and the reforms required in this regard.
Surabhi Yadav, AIR 14, 2025
Article 93-96 provides for the office of speaker of Lok Sabha & Article 178 for Speaker of Vidhan Sabha. He enjoys the prominent status.
Powers & functions
1. He maintains order & Decorum of the House 2. He decides if the bill is money bill or ordinary. Final decision. 3. He doesn't vote in 1st instance. But casting vote in case of tie. 4. He adjourns the house or suspend the meeting 5. He presides over the joint sitting of both the houses. 6. He decides the question of disqualification of a member of Lok Sabha & Vidhan Sabha. 7. He appoints chairman of all Parliamentary committee.
But Recently we saw certain criticism of Office of Speaker:-
1. Party Interest over National Interest - Refusing to allow certain debates - Allowing passing of Three farm Bills in unconstitutional manner. 2. Bills not referred to committee - In 2021 monsoon session, no bill referred to any select committee. 3. Increased disruption of Parliament - Opposition staging protest & walkout - eg Congress in Loksabha, SP in UP. 4. Favour ruling Party - Several anti defection cases rendered by SC
Way forward - Reforms
1. Ensure Independence - eg: In Britain, after being elected speaker, resign from party. - In India, N. Sanjiva Reddy resigned - should be encouraged. 2. Models G V Mavalankar - 1st speaker noted - 'once speaker, rise above party & politics, Speaker for all'.
Speaker is the head of legislative organ & guarantee of Democracy in law forming & Nation. He must be independent & strengthened beyond party politics.