Topper Copies

Despite awarding constitutional status to the National Commission for Backward Classes, there still remain issues with regard to inclusion/exclusion of communities in the OBC list. Discuss.

Surabhi Yadav, AIR 14, 2025

102nd Constitutional Amendment Act awarded constitutional status to NCBC. It strengthen its position, better protection and grievance redressal mechanism for the Backward Caste. However, there still remains certain

Issues

1. Recommendations of NCBC not binding on government. 2. Features of expert body, not provided in composition of new NCBC. 3. Inclusion/Exclusion of communities in OBC list a) Its the executive function, NCBC doesn't include castes in list, it only consulted. b) Doesn't have responsibility to define backwardness, so can't address challenge of demands of various castes to be included as BCs. c) Article 338B is silent on SC mandate on periodic revision of backward class list in consultation with NCBC. d) Recent dispute, if Union or State government has right to include castes in list. - Court - President restored power to state.

Way forward

a) Carry out extensive research and surveys. b) Define backwardness - lay down guidelines of inclusion/exclusion in OBC list c) Recommendation to be tabled in Parliament, with reasons to accept/reject suggestions.

NCBC is an important constitutional body that looks at important aspect of Socio-economic equality. It must be strengthened to bring equality in society.