Topper Copies

A case study on a transgender employee, Miss A, facing resistance from older colleagues at her workplace after the decriminalisation of Section 377, asking for the ethical issues involved, the options available, and the best course of action.

Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023

With decriminalization of section 377, we have inched closer to giving due respect to transgenders, but behaviourally we have a long way to go as highlighted in this case study.

(a) Ethical issues involved

1. Rights of (transgender) Miss A vs strong attitude of elder people 2. Moral responsibility to provide a safe working condition for A vs Image of the company 3. Immediate relief reqd to A vs longterm attitudinal change in employees 4. Rights of a human being vs unnecessary targetting her for being "something"

(b) Options available

(1) Accept resignation

| Pros | Cons | |---|---| | relief to Miss A | Injustice to Miss A | | sol'n to the persistent problem | Company's reputation compromised |

(2) Reject resignation & take no action

| Pros | Cons | |---|---| | upholding diversity | Miss A would be left discriminated | | company's name will remain high | free hand to others |

(3) Give formal notice to others to behave well

| Pros | Cons | |---|---| | Justice will look like its been done | cold war b/w Miss A and others | | | she would still be uncomfortable |

(4) behavioural change - take both short term & long term measures

| Pros | Cons | |---|---| | ensure acceptance of diversity | time required | | build trust | may not give instant relief to Miss A |

(c) It would be wise to choose option (4) as

1. Give time to others to accept change - strong attitudes require time to change. 2. Ensure that immediate problem of Miss A is solved by talking to others about her problem 3. hold seminars to make people aware about behaving well in face of diversity. 4. Operand conditioning - ensure people to those who behave well. 5. Use techniques of persuasion - speaker, message, technique should be apt to ensure people adhere to them. 6. Ask Miss A to explain her point of view to others.

Thus, such situations require not just organizational change but also attitudinal changes in their behaviour by effective training and persuasion.