Topper Copies

A case study on a pharmaceutical company weighing profit against ethical business practice, asking for the ethical dilemmas involved, the options available, and the ethical alternatives.

Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023

Such day-to-day ethical dilemmas are part of life and it is on the virtue of the actor to solve it.

(a) Ethical dilemmas faced in this context

1. Profit of company vs moral value 2. My own job vs Ethical value 3. Professional integrity vs. Commercial motive 4. Fighting off competition vs Taking the moral high ground 5. Sticking to code of Pharma vs Ensuring bounties for the company

(b) Options available

(1) Allow business as usual

| Pros | Cons | |---|---| | Profit for the company | Crisis of conscience | | achieving the target | losing out on morality |

(2) Disallow unethical practices

| Pros | Cons | |---|---| | Ethical high ground | lose out on profit | | No crisis of conscience | will not be able to remain competitive |

Choose 2nd option because 1. Professional integrity specially in healthcare sector is a must 2. Ensure public trust is maintained on the company. 3. Ethical advertisement practices will ensure "brand image" creation 4. Report unethical practices of other companies to ensure survival.

(c) Ethical alternatives

1. Give free samples to patients 2. Engage in healthy competiton 3. Report any unethical practice if done by any other company. 4. Collaborate with NGO's to ensure that a brand name is created for your company. 5. Ethical lobbying to ensure that other competitors dont use wrong techniques 6. Form an ethics committee which keep a check on all companies

Thus, to ensure public trust on pharma company, it should lead in adhering to moral standards.