A case study on Meera, who faces workplace harassment and is offered money by her boss to withdraw her complaint while needing funds for her mother's medical treatment, asking for the stakeholders, the issues of integrity and ethics involved, and the options available to Meera.
Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023
Cases of misconduct in office have been on a rise despite POSH act in force. Meera's case is a classic case of ethical dilemma's faced by a woman in pursuing such cases.
(a) Main stakeholders in the case
- Meera - victim - Boss - perpetrator of offence - Meera's Mother - who is in dire need of medical attention - Me - things are unfolding in front of me and I personally know both my boss and Meera and their attitude and behaviour - Society at large - any action has huge repurcussions on society at large and what Meera does today will have an example for future generations to follow.
(b) Issues related to integrity and ethics in this case
- Should Meera choose financial need over self respect. - Professional integrity vs Moral standards - future repurcussions, if no action is taken on the boss despite her complaint - fear of being branded as troublemaker - poorly reflected on Me, if I remain a bystander - manipulation by my boss → asking Meera to accept money. - self respect or mother's life - what should be kept on higher pedestal - An example for future - strict action now will dissuade the boss from repeating it in future.
Options available to Meera
(1) Accept the money, take the complaint back
| Pros | Cons | |---|---| | mother's health bills taken care of | crisis of conscience | | no future repurcussions on career | Branded as liar and greedy | | | against her Dharma |
(2) Dont accept the money, let the complaint proceed
| Pros | Cons | |---|---| | Moral Integrity upheld | Effect on her career | | Self Respect ensured | Mom's health bills compromised | | keep such offenders at bay | Boss has good reputation - he might go scotfree | | Moral compass towards justice | |
Meera should choose 2nd option and that will 1. Ensure no other woman faces this situation 2. Ensure she doesn't have to face crisis of conscience. 3. Her mother's health expenditure can be met by crowdfunding 4. Self respect should be kept at highest pedestal. 5. uphold "Sheelam Param Bhushanam" => character is the highest virtue.
Thus, to keep attitude-belief coherence, Meera should take the road less travelled and stay strong over her commitments.