You have recently been posted as a Nodal Education Officer in one of the districts, where mass cheating in examinations is a regular phenomenon. Media reports have shown parents and relatives scaling school walls and buildings to pass answer chits to students taking secondary school examinations in the district. Moreover, with the advent of new technological devices, cheating in examinations has become more sophisticated and exam rules are flouted openly. On investigation, it has come to your notice that these rackets are run by many school authorities, including exam invigilators who are mostly teachers, and they are hand in glove for profits. With a shortage of staff, invigilators threaten go on mass strikes if any action is taken. Conducting the exams, cancelling them on account of cheating and having re-exams are a loss of time and money for the government and this vicious cycle goes on. As the Nodal Education Officer of the district, address the following questions: (a) What are the ethical issues involved in the above case? (b) How will you resolve the issues in the given case? (c) What long-term strategy needs to be adopted to deal with the menace of cheating in various examinations? (Answer in 250 words)
Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023
With images of relatives scaling a Bihar school's wall and helping their children in cheating, this case study brings out the ethical dilemmas of it.
(a) Ethical issues involved
For students 1. They would be demotivated to conduct studies. 2. What about those who work hard - they will not be given justice
For school 3. How to manage staff shortage 4. What if the invigilators go on strike, who will conduct exams 5. Re-exams will cost the exchequer high
For society 6. What kind of school education system are we promoting? 7. Why are parents so keep on getting good marks for their child. 8. Why are the moral values of society stooping to such low levels.
(b) Resolving the Issue 1. Take appropriate action - like flying squads, etc to curb mass cheating 2. Employ adequate police staff to thoroughly check students for bluetooth devices etc. 3. If teachers go on strike, suspend them and ensure their salary is not given to them, alongwith an explanation letter being demanded. 4. Demand some extra staff from nearby districts - we have a lot of population and teachers from nearby districts can come to invigilate during exams 5. If above scheme isnt feasible due to any local constraint - conduct the exams in nearby district and employing flying squads 6. As the NEO, I can take personal rounds of few schools alternatively to ensure no cheating takes place. 7. Involve DM to ensure you get the adequate means to execute the plan. 8. Meanwhile involve the police to collect evidence against such corrupt teachers to terminate them from service
(c) Long term strategy (a) Enhance values of society by training, moral education lectures. (b) Innovative methods like- 1. Open book exams 2. Setting UPSC style Question papers - both Prelims and mains - reduce chances of cheating 3. Flying squads among teachers themselves 4. Online exams in other new areas
Thus, education based on Gandhiji's Nai Talim is the need of the hour to ensure learning by doing.