Topper Copies

A case study on a policewoman, Rupa, bringing her infant to the office, asking whether the act was justified, how personal and professional duties overlap, and whether Indian work culture hinders working mothers.

Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023

The dual burden on women have led to such instances gaining pace in the recent decade, like policewomen bringing their kids to office.

(a) If act was justified

Yes: 1. Biological need - Child has to be breastfed. 2. Importance to work - if a civil servant is off duty, huge amount of pending work will remain. 3. Highest workmanship of professional integrity. 4. International example - Jacinda Ardern, New zealand's PM did the same. 5. Always a challenge for new mothers to balance her office & the child => criticism of it will make her life hell 6. Trying to find a middle ground for the same

No: 1. child will be prone to disease and pathogens and without the child's immunity getting developed => challenge. 2. Even for Rupa - It might not be the best available option as she would be low on energy and immunity. 3. Work is a means to an end, not an end in itself. She should first prioritize herself and the child.

Overlap between personal and professional duties

1. Actor - Since the actor is common (i.e Rupa), there is bound to be an overlap. 2. Essence of life - is to make a balance between personal and professional life 3. Better use of legal mandate - Utilize maternity leave and simultaneously do the most essential task at hand in office 4. Natural requirement - Formative years of child's development requires that mother is there for feeding the child. 5. Role of society - Society should ensure that entry of a woman into motherhood is made easier by invoking societal alternatives

(b) Work culture in India hinders working mothers

1. less availability of creche in offices 2. Informal sector women remain largely outside legal avenues available for formal sector women 3. less responsibility of father to take care of child. 4. As in this case, balancing of child rearing and professional commitment is seen as a publicity stunt 5. Nuclear families proliferance has further accentuated the problem. 6. Poor infrastructural mechanisms further put burden on working women. 7. Work culture- support from seniors and juniors is a must to ensure that a lady is able to take care of the child.

Work culture - enabling working mothers to fulfil their role

1. Maternity act and such laws enable working mother's responsibility is fulfilled. 2. Mostly colleagues are supportive. Ex-Elderly women bringing in good food for new mothers is part of Indian ethos. 3. Examples of efficient work culture is APJ Kalam taking officers kids for movies to fulfil his familial obligations. 4. Often extended families help in raising the child, which adds on to good work culture.

Thus, balancing work and personal life is a new challenge posed by modernity and work ethics should mould itself to make this job easier.