There are various issues related to appointments in higher judiciary in India that need urgent attention. Discuss in context of the recent report by the Parliamentary Standing Committee for the Ministry of Law and Justice.
Surabhi Yadav, AIR 14, 2025
Parliamentary standing committee in its recent investigation found many issues with appointments in higher judiciary.
1. Lack of socio-economic representation 2. Vacancies - approved strength 1080, appointed only 661, in High court. Reason - No time frame in which Central government approve recommendation by judicial committee - Non finalisation of Memorandum of procedure b/w Executive & Judiciary 3. High rate of rejection by Central government of recommended candidates. - Nearly 40-50% rejected. 4. Lack of transparency on committees part of basis of selection & recommendation.
Way forward
1. System like NJAC - that have Member of both executive and judiciary for appointment. 2. Separate committee to carry out solely appointments. 3. All India Judicial Services introduce. 4. Better representation to women & minority/vulnerable sections. 5. Lay down guidelines for selection for appointments.
Thus, judiciary need revamp in appointment of judges to bind up 3crore+ cases pending with Indian Judiciary.