The disproportionate preference for government jobs in certain Indian states is not merely a matter of personal aspiration. Analyze.
Surabhi Yadav, AIR 14, 2025
Government jobs from clerk to peons, to IAS & IES services have all been desirable over any private jobs.
Disproportionate Preference in States like Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, Haryana, Madhya Pradesh
Reason for Preference
A. Personal aspiration -> for job security & regular/certain income.
B. Other reasons overpower: 1. Societal prestige - promotion through Reels/YouTube as prestigious life. 2. Ticket to better dowry -> (eg) Groom prices in states like UP: IAS - 80 lakh, Engineer in Govt - 20 lakh, etc. 3. Association with power. (eg) Jobs like IPS, Inspector, Constable mobilise for power roles. 4. Perceived notion of additional income of corruption, ie 'Upar ki Aamdani' as motivation factor. 5. Family pressure over personal choices. 6. Limited private sector jobs availability also push them. (eg) Bihar, private companies.
Ways to Address
1. Societal changes -> Mindset through nudging - better salary; women education. 2. Institutional changes -> Better skill education (only w.r.t. current); attract private companies. (eg) NOIDA. 3. Policy changes -> Increase PPP; NEP 2020 focus on skilling & better employability.