Topper Copies

Bring out the similarities and differences in the Bill of Rights in the Constitution of the United States and Fundamental Rights in the Constitution of India.

Surabhi Yadav, AIR 14, 2025

Bill of Rights was brought about in United States by the 1st-10 Amendments to its constitution, and Fundamental Rights in Indian Constitution have been derived from it.

Similarities

1. Same in essence - to protect human rights. 2. Upholds individual rights rather than collective rights as a society. 3. Includes concept of freedom of speech, expression. 4. Upholds idea of equality - India - caste based - USA - black & white 5. Upholds the principle of secularism. Do not discriminate based on any individual's religious beliefs. 6. Against exploitation.

Differences

1. Allows keeping arms and guns for protection of life & liberty - USA. In India, guaranteed by Supreme Court, stringent laws against personal weapons. 2. USA - Includes human, legal and other rights as well. India - fundamental Rights.

| USA | India | |---|---| | Rule of law | Procedure established by law | | Right to property | It has now became a legal right under article 300-A | | Federal courts enforce Bill of Rights | Supreme Court protects the Fundamental Rights |

Thus, we saw some difference in rights guaranteed by USA and India. But they are largely similar in their essence & what they try to achieve. We need to continuously preserve individual rights to protect humans from discriminations.