Topper Copies

A case study on the ethics of mass layoffs by corporations following the "Great Resignation", asking who the stakeholders are, why such conduct occurs, and what measures could address it.

Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023

After 'the Great Resignation', the recent trend has shifted to "Mass layoffs" - which is a severe hit to Professional integrity of corporates.

(a) Stakeholders involved

Ethical issues surrounding mass layoffs

1. Profit Motivation vs moral responsibility to employees. 2. Inefficient use of Power differentials in society → who decides who will get laid off (will promote sychophancy) 3. Reflects Poorly on Professional integrity 4. Moral Pain for employees losing their jobs => how are they supposed to Trust and bond with next job (moral dilemma) 5. Clear violation of Kant's philosophy of not using man as a means to an end. 6. Will increase alienation in working, as a virtuous employee would be losing out on his personal life => only to get sacked. 7. Youth will consequently have less dedication to public service as they wouldn't have an attitude of positivity towards work culture

(b) Reasons behind irresponsible conduct

1. lack of professional integrity 2. see employees merely as means to achieve the goal of profitability. 3. Inability to see the 'golden mean' in this situation and taking adverse step of mass layoffs 4. Priortise other's sufferings over reducing their own comfort 5. Forgetting their dharma of service to humanity, by prioritising their own profits 6. Lack of resources and capital - Prefer layoff than going bankrupt.

(c) Measures to tackle these problems

1. follow ethos of compassionate capitalism. Ex - Reduce pay of all employees, dont remove employees from payroll 2. Find a Madhyamarg - between mass lay offs and full employment. Ex - keep them on lesser pay for some time till company recoups 3. Moral integrity would require that they ensure these workers good, as they have resources to cater to them. 4. Take help from civil society and govt to ensure their wellbeing. 5. 'Yatho Praja Tatho sabha' → Corporate leaders can lead by example and forego their salaries during dire times.

Thus, the startups culture should ensure that work is accompanied with ethics to ensure that workers aren't alienated from their jobs.