Topper Copies

In a metropolitan city of India, the law enforcement authorities decided to adopt facial recognition technology to improve their crime-fighting capabilities. They implemented a facial recognition system that integrated with existing surveillance cameras across the city, allowing real-time identification and tracking of individuals. The system was intended to assist in identifying known criminals, missing persons, and suspects in ongoing investigations. One evening, a woman reported a mugging incident where the perpetrator wore a hoodie, obscuring most of his face. The victim provided a vague description to the police, and based on that information, the authorities decided to use facial recognition technology to locate potential suspects. The system scanned through hours of surveillance footage from various locations near the crime scene. The facial recognition algorithm generated a list of potential matches, and one individual's image stood out as a close match to the description provided by the victim. The police considered this individual a prime suspect and proceeded with his arrest. Subsequently, it was discovered that the arrested person was innocent. Further investigation revealed that the facial recognition system had misidentified the innocent individual due to the limitations of the technology and the partial description provided by the victim. The police released the arrested individual; still his reputation got tarnished for life. He, along with his family, was evicted from their current place of residence. The psychological impact of the incident has been tremendous owing to which his job is also on the line. With reference to this case, answer the following: (a) What are the issues involved in this case? (b) What measures can be taken to minimize the negative implications of adopting such technologies? (Answer in 250 words)

Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023

The rising cases of limits of technology at a time when we have understood as Panacea of all problems, has given rise to such a situation.

(a) Issues involved in the above case 1. Moral responsibility of tarnishing the innocent's life. 2. Failure of technology - who should be blamed in such cases. 3. Why were no procedural safeguards taken care of before actually arresting a person. 4. Was it legal to completely rely on technology and arrest a person without evidence. 5. Who gave the order to arrest a person without conducting proper checks 6. Why were no forensic investigation done before arresting him - viz his phone location etc. 7. Why were there lack of checks and balances - can means justify the ends of it? 8. Affected stakeholders -> tarnished police image, person who got arrested, his family, society at large. 9. How can over-reliance over technology justify actual arrest of a person and give no moral accountibility of investigation agencies.

(b) Measures to minimize the negative implications of adopting such technologies: 1. Effective checks and Balances - No arrest without evidence 2. Indian law assumes a person "innocent until proven guilty" -> This should form the basic premise. 3. Abuse of power strictly punished - arresting people without evidence would scar them for life. 4. Concrete Digital Evidence - unless human eyes also are able to identify a perpetrator, no arrest should take place. 5. Technological upgrade - to ensure it works with "zero failure" rates and gives accurate results. 6. Codified rules - in clear terms of when an arrest can be made. 7. Make citizen's more aware of their rights against detention and arrest 8. Ensure Right to be forgotten to the person 9. Man should not be used as a means to an end (Kant's philosophy) 10. Respect privacy of a person (K.S. Puttaswamy judgement)

As sophmodes said "Nothing great ever comes to man without an inherent devil"

We should ensure this devil doesnt eat up someone's liberty (Art21) and dignity.