Topper Copies

Low tax buoyancy often translates into higher deficits and debt. Can a higher direct tax rate improve the overall tax-to-GDP ratio in India? What other steps can be undertaken to revamp the overall tax structure in India?

Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023

Tax buoyancy refers to the rate at which tax collection increases with one percent rise of GDP and remains grossly low in India.

Low tax buoyancy translating into higher Deficits Grow rate 7% + low tax buoyancy (GST collected 1.5 lakh cror) -> Fiscal deficit 6.4%, CAD = 2%, External Debt to GDP = 20%

Tax to GDP ratio hovers around 15-17% i.e 1% GDP rise will only enhance tax by 15% (way below China ~28%)

Higher direct tax rate - a solution? Yes 1. Direct tax contributes 52% to tax and its rate increase, might result into higher tax collection 2. Easy to collect direct tax as it can be TDS or TCS (Tax deducted at Source, Tax collected at Source) 3. Staggered approach - of enhancing direct tax rate for ultra rich and similar tax rate for the poor.

No 1. Laffer curve - after peak tax collection point A, tax collection will reduce as tax rate keeps rising. 2. Would act as brakes in economy by reducing purshasing power and thereby decreasing demand 3. A proportional tax rate increase would have a regressive effect on tax collection. 4. Structural deficiencies of economy can't be sewed with enhancing tax rates 5. 48% of tax collection comes from indirect taxes => they should be rationalized.

Other steps taken to revamp overall tax structure 1. One Nation, One Tax Rate - GST is steadily moving in this direction 2. Simplifying tax structure to enhance compliance. Ex- New tax rates without external benefits, just one rate to pay 3. Direct Tax Code - Committee by Akhilesh Ranjan 4. GST Council meetings ensure that tax on various commodities are simplified. Ex- Roti-Parantha conundrum 5. Vivad se Vishwas scheme to resolve issues of tax collection 6. e-ITR filing for faceless assessment and less bureaucratic hurdle. 7. Taxes like Angel Tax reduced to enhance corporate economy. (30%->22% Corporate Tax)

Thus, to enhance tax buoyancy, use of IT in tax collection is a must (Akhilesh Ranjan Task force)