Topper Copies

Most civil servants are neither pure deontologists nor pure utilitarians, but they operate according to a kind of ethical pluralism." Do you agree? Discuss your position with suitable examples.

Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023

While deontology deals with reliance on an over duty (Kant), Utilitarianism (Bentham) desires maximum pleasure for maximum number of people.

Emerging challenges and new governance models require civil servants to employ a mix of above methods, viz - Ethical pluralism -:

1. Avoid Ritualism - Too much duty oriented leads to red tapism and formation of Ivory Tower. New age governance should refrain from being ritualistic. Ex - IAS Rahul Kumar ate at a widow's house (not his duty per se)

2. Innovation in justice delivery - allowing elderly without matching fingerprints access to PDS ration is an innovative definition of one's duty -> not just serve people, but also make their lives easier.

3. Climate Reparations - Utilitarian approach would highlight that all nations should equally contribute for climate change adaptations, but Common But differentiated Responsibility approach added the element of Justice in it.

4. Multiple variables - Felicacy Calculus that measures pain and pleasure, now has risk associated to it. Ex- stalling of development projects during COVID-19

5. Fortitude during times of distress by Durga shakti against sand Mafias

6. Humane approach to governance needs ethical pluralism. Ex- Collector bro Pransath Nair's Operation Sulemaan.

Thus, ethical pluralism is a pre-requiste to ensure Summum bonum - the greatest good for one and all.