While impartiality has been identified as one of the key ethical values for public service, it should not be seen as precluding compassion in public service. Discuss.
Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023
Impartiality is the ability to choose between two options without being biased and based on objectivity. Compassion, is to understand other's viewpoint and act empathetically on it.
Public service to be done by mixing impartiality + Compassion, as
1. Ensure social justice - Equity in governance requires both. Eg- Affirmative action to undo historical Injustice, prevents social darwinism
[diagram: two panels. Left panel labelled "impartiality" shows two stick figures of different heights standing on equal-height podiums, unable to see over a wall. Right panel labelled "Impartiality + Compassion" shows the same two figures standing on podiums of different heights so both can see over the wall.]
2. Last mile delivery of public service ensured Ex- home delivery of Identification documents to old age people, divyangjans => classic case of Impartiality + Compassion. 3. Prevents social exclusion - as it imbibes everyone's good will while decision making. Ex- allowing PDS to an elderly woman, whose fingerprints aren't matching with adhar database 4. To uphold Gandhian Philosophy - promoting antyodaya through sarvodaya. Ex - Universal Healthcare system, but with special emphasis on women. 5. will influence societal functioning Ex - Compassionate corporate governance to be incorporated in working.
But, sometimes impartially has to prelude compassion → 1. in competitive exams - impartiality is must 2. in case of delivering justice Ex- a judge can't favour a party on compassionate grounds 3. allocating jobs - impartial judgement of skills over someone's family background.
Thus, Public service delivery requires a judicious mix of impartiality and compassion to fulfill the tenets of Nishkama Karma.