Naveen and Vinod, final year undergraduate students at ABC college of engineering, are close friends. Naveen has been a meritorious student and got appointed as the secretary of the training and placement cell, which has the mandate to oversee the campus placements of the students. Vinod, on the other hand, spent more time on leisure activities and paid less attention to his academic performance. However, the lackadaisical attitude of Vinod began to reflect on his grades. His poor performance in the majority of subjects meant that he had to complete some courses again, in order to graduate in time. As Vinod struggled to complete his extra courses, he barely had any time left for anything else. The immense fatigue was also evident from his deteriorating physical and psychological health. Around this time the campus placement in the ABC college had started. While all other students were preparing for the recruitment tests, Vinod had barely any time for the same. Vinod's parents, who had taken loan for Vinod's education, are expecting Vinod to get a good job. The guilt of wasting his college years and letting down his poor parents was becoming unbearable for Vinod, as a result of which he had a nervous breakdown. Naveen, who in his capacity as secretary of training and placement cell, was busy organising the recruitment drive, was aware that the chances of Vinod getting recruited were very slim. He also knew that Vinod was repenting in true sense and working very hard to complete his courses, despite his deteriorating emotional health. Naveen was afraid that if Vinod did not get a job, he may take some extreme step. Naveen has in his possession the question paper for the recruitment test to be held next week. Vinod had in the past requested Naveen to help him in any way possible to get a decent job. While Naveen knows that sharing the questions with Vinod may help him get through the exam, it would be ethically incorrect. Now, Naveen is in a dilemma over the course of action he should take. a) What are the ethical dilemmas before Naveen in this case? b) Identify and evaluate the various courses of actions available before Naveen. If you were in Naveen's shoes, which course of action would you choose and why?
Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023
Ethical dilemmas before Naveen
1. Friendship vs public duty- his duty as placement head requires him to be fair while he knows Vinod really needs a job. 2. Being ethical vs choosing a wrong means for helping a friend- cheating in any form is wrong, even if done for a friend. 3. Private relationship vs public responsibility- leaking question papers would go against interest of other students who have done their best during college years. 4. Justice vs Favouritism- using a "veil of ignorance" to ensure justice would go against the friend's interest.
Options available
1. Leaking questions- benefit for Vinod, but totally wrong for other hard working students and also the company in which he might go, despite not having the calibre. Strict No No to the action. 2. Use the Golden Mean- Madhya Marg a. Don't leak the question paper, so that the most eligible person gets the job and the name of the college doesnt go down- recruiting company should get a meritocratic person. b. Meanwhile, help Vinod to not just clear the exam, but also uplift his skills for the next placement exam. - crowdfund money to give him extra coaching - emotional support from friends to ensure he doesnt take an extreme step. - help from college faculty to help him sail through. 3. No help, no leaking of papers- will go against ethics in private relationships and fail the standards of friendship.
Thus, option 2 would be the go to option to ensure means and ends both are satisfied and interest of all are taken care of.