Topper Copies

Q5. There is an entrepreneur who has opened a factory in the rural areas for the manufacture of sanitary ware. His initiative has helped in providing good employment opportunity to rural people and in the production of affordable sanitary products which are being used in construction of rural toilets. However there are some cases of under payment of wages and few cases of employment of children below 14 yrs. You are labour enforcement officer of the area and in course of your routine inspection, you noticed these discrepancies. Answer the following. (a) What are the options available to you? (b) Discuss the merits/demerits of each option and finally choose the option which you consider best with suitable justifications.

Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023

The problem here is of making the entrepreneur face the legal issues as well as the ethical issues of not taking in child labour. The following options are available -

1. Reporting the matter - This would engulf the entrepreneur in a legal battle and may even lead to closure of the factory leading to loss of employment. This absolutism would prove fatal. 2. Issuing a warning to the entrepreneur and taking a written note from him that he would not repeat the same in future. This would be a win win situation for all. 3. Regular audit would ensure that he is checked time and again and prevented from doing any wrongdoing. This would also keep him in check so that he never resorts to unfair means. 4. The community needs to be assured that they should not tolerate child labour or low wages. This would ensure social accountability of the entrepreneur. 5. Not taking an action is not the solution.

Steps 2-4 will have to be taken in combination to ensure good of all.