Topper Copies

Q4. Due to fall in agricultural productivity and faulty procurement policy, a marginal family head has committed suicide and left his family and two children, daughter (12 years) and son (8 years). They shifted to nearby city in search of work and ended up living in a slum. Both children had to leave their studies and mother went searching for some household work. Finally she is a maid at your home. She works at your personal residence. One day she felt ill and ask her daughter to continue in place of her. Your wife is an IAS officer and quite busy. She does not have time to take care of old in-laws who needs constant care. Though there is a nurse to take care of them but there is a need of help in small household works also. So she gave consent to daughter of maid to continue in place of her. As she fears that your family may engage someone else and she will loose livelihood opportunity. When you raised the concern, she replied that this is matter of few weeks only, and also saying no will bring them on street. As in such a metro city one cannot survive without work, everything has a cost. You are Mayor of the city. (a) What are the ethical dilemmas related to it? (b) Your wife is in support of her placement as domestic worker as it will help her in balancing household and work responsibilities. Do you find her justification right? (c) How will you persuade her to change her decision?

Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023

Ethical dilemmas involved here are whether to deprive one of her daily bread and on the other the illegal act of employing an underage. The problem has another layer to it - as to how to ensure proper rates for a farmer's produce so that s/he can live comfortably.

Also, the children should be in school at this age instead of searching for work. One needs to ensure that they are given proper schooling, simultaneously ensuring that they don't work (being underage).

(b) The wife is right in demanding that they shouldn't be deprived their daily bread, but the solution for this can't be child labour. Despite being in informal employment, the maid can be given paid holidays (as one belongs to a prosperous family, monetary allowances won't be a problem).

A temporary worker can be roped in (may be through the maid only) to work for a few weeks as a substitute.

(c) The wife herself being an IAS officer would be empathetic (for she wants the maid's family to get their income), can be convinced to give her paid leaves. Since, the maid is ill, she can be offered treatment at govt hospitals at a subsidised rate.

Also, to use our demographic dividend we need to send the children to the school. All these suggestions would invoke sympathy and empathy in the wife.

Also, she should be requested to keep in check that farmers are paid their dues so that in the long term, they are not forced to commit suicides.