Topper Copies

Q3. You are a head of Water Supply Board of a district town and in-charge of supplying drinking water to the people. You had a detailed consultation with people regarding a Citizen Charter for water supply services. Based on the requirement and expectations of people, you had a discussion with your subordinates who were little reluctant about the Charter but seeing your positive attitude they ultimately agreed. You committed some hurry in implementation of the Charter and notice the following problems: 1. The quantum of water promised could not be ensured. 2. The quality of water did not improve. 3. One of your key functionaries went on a long leave and you did not get his replacement. 4. The entire blame on the failure of the Charter came on you. Ponder over the situation and answer the following questions: (a) What were the reasons of failure of the Citizen Charter? (b) What should have been ideal course of action and why? (c) Draw a Citizen's Charter for this case.

Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023

The problem here is of dereliction of duties mentioned in the citizen charter. Since, the objective of the charter was to achieve transparency, the teething problems need to be calmly handled.

(a) Reasons of failure of citizen charter -

While undue haste in implementation of citizen's charter seems to be the prima facie cause, but deeper issues also can't be overlooked, like -

1. Presence of no reference for charter in that department 2. Overestimation of available water supplies 3. Ignoring the fact that cleaning the water would require funding & technology upgradation 4. Non-availability of skilled worker to replace the on-leave employee (situational constraint) 5. People's participation was not ensured

(b) The ideal course of action should have been to employ all staff workers to get an account of ground realities, to prepare the charter.

Also, past records of amount of water supply and the right assessment of quality of water that can be delivered should have been taken into account.

Also, the public should be taken into confidence that a new initiative is bound to have teething problems and a smooth ride would be difficult to achieve.

(c) Citizen's Charter — Name of the department

The office guarantees the citizens the following services - - Amount of water available in locality would range from x lpcd to y lpcd. - The quality of water would strictly adhere to BIS norms. - Timing of water supply - 24 hrs. - In case of a grievance, contact the grievance officer.