Q1. You are a Superintendent of Police and a huge protest is going on infront of your office. These protesters are Human Right activists. Protest is because of two consecutive incidents happened in your district. Case one: City SP has received intelligence input that bombs have been planted in various places in the city. SP asked his team for massive search operation. After putting in strenuous hard work, police team raided a house where two people with 2 kg of explosives and IED devices were found. Police team immediately arrested them and brought them to the police station. Police started interrogating them related to the whereabouts of the bombs and their plans. When they failed to take out information from them, one of the Police Officer adopted third degree. Torture in case of new criminals often works. But one of the person died during the process, as he failed to bear the pain of torture. Death in police custody became a big issue. Case two: Recently communal riots occured held in your area and few police constables got surrounded by a group, viewing the grave situation and possible threat on life, one of the constable picked a man as a human shield. They found it as easy way to escape as that could also save the life of other police constables. But while they were trying to escape, people started stone pelting and the person who was used as human shield get badly injured. However, he was saved later by proper treatment. Answer the following questions: (a) Analyse the ethical dilemmas you will face as SP in both the stated situations. (b) Human Rights Activists are demanding action against official involved in both the cases. What will be your course of action? (c) Police Chief of State reaches to you and asks for not taking any action, as it will bring down the morals of the police force. What will be your course of action? (d) Can you justify the use of torture technique in any given circumstances? (e) Would you justify the use of human shield to save the lives of your colleagues? Give reasons. What are the moral and ethical issues involved in using human shield as the method of action against agitating mob?
Medha Anand, AIR 13, 2023
Ethical dilemmas faced in the mentioned cases will be -
Case one - Custodial death has ignited the protest, but third degree was used by the police for ensuring public safety and not for personal gains. As a SP, charging the police team would set wrong precedent, while maintaining the status quo would enrage the public.
Case two - Ethical dilemma here would be whether to charge the team for wrong doing, who acted on situational discretion to save one's own life. While using a human shield is not ethical at all, but even the police have Human Right to be saved.
Both the cases have dilemmas, to solve which a hierarchy of values will have to be made and choice will have to be made to take a right step.
Also, J.S. Mill's concept of whether the deed is worthy of punishment, even if it was morally wrong, will have to be used.
(b) To reduce protests, immediate measure of taking Human Right activists into confidence needs to be taken up. An enquiry should be set up to look into the circumstances to give an assurance to the people in both the cases.
(c) Police chief's consideration should also be taken into cognizance and once the enquiry submits its report, it should be established whether the actions are worthy of punishment even if they are morally wrong.
(d) While torture technique can't be justified at any cost, but police should have situational discretion to use third degree, when it has to save lives of a large number of people, i.e. Utilitarian approach of maximum good for maximum number of people can be applied here.
(e) Using human shield is not justified, but situational discretion might have guided the police personnel to use it for their safety. In a bid to save one's own lives, the police might have been prompted to do that way. But, this should not become a norm and strict guidelines on not resorting to such drastic measures should be released, as it is not morally sound to use Man as a means (Kant's categorical imperative); also one would not himself like to be treated as such.