Topper Copies

You are a Foreign Service official working in an embassy overseas. One of your duties was to liaise with the local Indian community, one of the country's largest immigrant groups. A group of wealthy Indian immigrants wanted to build a place of worship and a school to promote their language and culture. The school was intended to act as a center for promoting and preserving Indian culture among the immigrants. The Indian community leaders went through all the legal procedures to acquire the land, got the building plans approved by the city council, and with all the approvals in place, the construction work began. A few months into the construction, the locals started complaining about noise, and slowly a campaign began against the construction of a religious structure. The local city councilors joined in and raised the issue of how Indian immigrants having their own cultural space will lead to a similar demand from other immigrant communities. And this may escalate intolerance among different ethnic groups. The local politicians filed a public lawsuit to halt the construction and demolish whatever was built. Indian community responded with their lawsuit and approached the embassy for help. They wanted the Ambassador to take up the issue with the government. Meanwhile, the Ambassador deputed you to meet the Indian community leaders to understand the issue and prepare a report. You met with the community leaders and found that the reason for local antipathy towards the Indian community was just an expression of latent racism and intolerance. You presented your observations to the Ambassador and requested him to do something as the Indians were on the right and were being victims of racist behavior. The Ambassador, in turn, replied that he would not like to get involved in local politics. The Indians were citizens of that country; they had nothing to do with India besides ethnicity. Further, a crucial Economic agreement was about to be signed between the two countries in the coming weeks, and he did not want to jeopardize the growing relations between the two countries over some local politics. You were shocked to see economics getting priority over the diaspora. (a) What are the issues involved in the above case? (b) Do you agree with the Ambassador's position of prioritizing economics over helping the diaspora? Why/why not? (c) Among Care, Consequentialism, and Duty, what do you think is the appropriate perspective to guide Indian Foreign policy? Justify. (Answer in 250 words) 20 Marks

Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023

The given issue reminds of recent attacks and incidents of vandalism against Indian temples in Australia, USA, etc.

(a) Issues involved 1. Racism, against human dignity. 2. Hyphenation of issues → against bureaucratic objectivity. 3. Intolerance on grounds of religion. 4. Ambassador not concerned about diaspora → against duty/deontological ethics (as one of the foremost duties of Indian foreign service is building diaspora ties).

(b) Do you agree with the Ambassador's position According to the given case, the Ambassador makes an assumption that taking up the issue of the temple will jeopardize the economic deal. That assumption may not be true.

Hence: 1. I first disagree with the assumption. 2. It is possible that the foreign authorities deal with the diaspora issue separately, and objectively. 3. Even if the assumption is right, I believe it is the Ambassador's duty to convince that they are independent issues. 4. In fact, resolving diaspora issues may make the economic deal more successful, if it may lead to greater people-to-people connect, hence more benefit from trade to both partners. 5. Thus, while prioritizing economics over helping the diaspora as a last resort may be correct from the point of utilitarian ethics, not trying to help the diaspora at all is definitely unethical.

(c) Guiding principles of foreign policy Foremost: consequentialism. Next: care and duty.

Consequentialism: national interest supreme → realist international ethics.

Care and duty (duty towards): for diaspora, for issues of global commons, for global south, for disaster victims, etc.

The attempt must be to align the three values, as India already does, via the theme of Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam at the G20 Summit.