Topper Copies

You are a young police officer undergoing field training along with some of your batchmates. You and Vikas are spending two weeks in a police station learning the nitty gritty and nuances of field-level policing. Every day there was something new to learn. One afternoon the Station received a distress call from a beat constable working the wholesale market beat. A quarrel had broken out between two groups of traders and which soon turned violent. He tried intervening with his colleague, but they failed to keep things in control. Some traders turned against the constables and started beating them with iron rods. The call came in when one of the constables had taken severe blows to the head, and he needed emergency attention. A team rushed to the spot to help and take charge of the situation. By the time the team reached, the miscreants had fled the scene. The injured constable was rushed to the hospital in a very precarious condition. Seeing their colleague severely hurt and struggling for life, the station was enraged and determined to apprehend the culprits. By late evening the station team had rounded up a few miscreants, but some were still missing. The rounded-up miscreants were kept in custody for the night and were to be presented in court the following day. That night you and Vikas noticed that a few senior policemen were seriously beating up the miscreants for more information and to teach them a lesson to keep off from policemen. The "treatment" continued for a few hours, and by the time it stopped, one of the miscreants was severely shaken that he had a minor stroke because of a prior history of a heart condition. He was rushed to the hospital; fortunately, he survived. When the events of the night reached HQ, an inquiry was instituted. During the inquiry, everyone in the Station was called in for questioning. All of them present played down the beatings as few slaps and nothing more. You and Vikas were also informally requested to play down the incident. Vikas was comfortably underplaying it, but you were uncomfortable and felt it was against your integrity to speak something far from the truth. You were wondering if police are for safety, custody is for protection, and what happened was abuse which was against the service values. You were tensed and weighed the options. (a) What are the ethical issues involved in the above case? (b) What do you think principle-oriented and rule-abiding police personnel must do in the above case? Why? Justify (c) What do you think must assume priority in civil service, loyalty to the department, or being impartial and non-partisan in your decisions and service values? (Answer in 250 words) 20 Marks

Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023

The given case reminds of various cases of custodial deaths, such as the recent death of Jeyaraj in Tamil Nadu.

(a) Ethical issues 1. Citizens (traders) not responding to police constables for peace → against civic duty. 2. Traders turning violent → illegal action. 3. Custodial violence. Illegal (IPC Act). 4. Lying to HQ inquiry: against ethics of integrity, honesty, etc.

(b) What principle-oriented and rule-abiding police personnel must do In my opinion, principle-oriented/rule-abiding personnel must have the courage to speak out the truth.

1. In line with police values: - S → Sensitive - M → Modern - A → Accountable - R → Reliable - T → Trained (acronym due to PM Modi)

Custodial violence displays → lack of sensitivity → lack of accountability → lack of reliability → lack of training.

2. Illegal custodial violence is illegal. Hence, lying may mean becoming party to a crime. 3. Duty to speak the truth (nishkam karma). 4. Means are as important as ends: "an eye for an eye will make the whole world blind", and the traders beating up police doesn't give police the right to retaliate in custody. 5. In line with utilitarian ethics:

Thus, the truth must be spoken.

(c) Loyalty to department vs impartiality Being impartial and non-partisan is not in contradiction with loyalty to the department. This is because: 1. Loyalty to the department involves upholding the values of the department (in this case, SMART). 2. Being partial/lying → values not upheld → disloyalty to the department.

True loyalty is in doing duty in letter and spirit; if one doesn't raise voice against wrongdoing/illegal action, that is not loyalty, it is cowardice.