You and Ajay were in college together, qualified for the civil services examination, trained, and worked in the same State. Over the years, you and Ajay became good friends and colleagues. Even the families became close to the extent of taking vacations and celebrating festivals together. Professionally, in the last 15 years, both grew, but the paths you and Ajay took differed. You kept your distance from political masters, preferred to be neutral, and refrained from being identified with any group, lobby, or ideology. But Ajay was not discreet about his leanings, and he was well-networked and connected. Because of his networking, Ajay always had postings considered "plum postings." Ajay was posted as CMD of Urban Infrastructure Projects, a high-profile Project with a huge outlay. At the same time, you were working in State Planning Commission for three years and were awaiting your promotion and new posting. When new postings were announced, you were surprised to see your transfer to Vigilance Department. Within a month of taking charge, you were ordered by your Departmental Secretary to conduct an inquiry discreetly into land dealings involving a Minister and his family. You were strictly told to keep it discreet and not to share any information about the investigation with anybody besides the Secretary. As you started the inquiry, you realized Ajay was closely involved with the Minister and his deals. As evidence started piling up, you were shocked to notice Ajay's questionable decisions favoring the Minister and friends. Further, you found evidence of Ajay having assets disproportionately much higher than his declared sources of income. When you shared the details with the Secretary, he immediately ordered you to search Ajay's office and home as he believed Ajay was the medium through which they could catch the Minister for shady land deals. You were in a bind as you knew a search operation would tarnish Ajay's reputation and be traumatic for the family. (a) What are the ethical issues and dilemmas involved in the above case? (b) What are the options available to you? (c) Select your chosen course of action after analyzing the options. (d) What must be your moral motivation in the above case? Should it be duty, care, or consequences? (Answer in 250 words) 20 Marks
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
The given case reminds of the case of the criminal Pooja Singhal in Jharkhand recently.
(a) Ethical issues 1. Lack of Ajay's political neutrality. 2. Assets disproportionate to income → (ie) sign of corruption. 3. Shady land dealings of the Minister, and violation of public trust, violation of oath of office, cheating the citizens. 4. Bureaucrat-politician nexus → against accountability.
(b) Options available 1. Decline to search on account of friendship with Ajay. 2. Do duty without fear.
(c) Analysis and chosen course of action Option 1: 1. Corruption and politician-bureaucrat criminal nexus hurts ordinary people the most → thus, not acting is against utilitarian ethics. 2. Not acting is against the principle of promise to the organisation. 3. Against deontological ethics (as it is the duty of the vigilance dept to investigate corruption). 4. It may implicate myself in the nexus → it is against my own interests.
Thus, it is an extremely unethical option.
Option 2: 1. In line with duty, utilitarianism, loyalty to organisation. 2. (ie) ethical.
Hence, my chosen course of action is Option 2.
(d) Moral motivation Corruption costs more than 5% in GDP growth, according to think tanks, and according to organisations such as Transparency International.
This does not harm the rich or the well-off; it disproportionately harms the poorest, the most vulnerable, the marginalized. (eg) corruption in food security programs is directly linked to the death of citizens who die of malnutrition. (eg) corruption in delivery of agriculture services is linked to suicide of farmers.
Thus, my foremost moral motivation in the given case must be that of care: care for the victims of corruption, care for the lives and families of those which corruption takes.
Next, moral motivation, that of duty.
Finally, that of consequences (of inaction).
As ex-PM Vajpayee said, "corruption is a crime against humanity."