A major pharmaceutical company headquartered in Mumbai had worldwide operations. It was a big producer and exporter of generic drugs. It has production facilities spread around the country. After the pandemic, the company saw an exponential growth in demand for its generic drugs, and to meet the demand, the company contracted out production to small manufacturers. The deal was that the contracted supplier would supply a specified quantity of drugs within the prearranged schedule, and on delivery, the payments were released. The company didn't bother about the supplier's facilities, policies, or safety standards. It was a simple business deal of keeping the supply chain running without liabilities. Some suppliers saw this as an opportunity to make some quick money. They started stretching the limits of their production facility and didn't mind compromising with safety and labor laws. Unfortunately, a supplier's storage facility caught fire, and 22 workers died in the tragedy. The production facility was closed, and the dead workers' families sued the supplier and pharmaceutical company for damages. The supplier agreed to pay the damages, but the company denied any liabilities as they were not directly involved. Meanwhile, the lawyers representing the family claimed that the company was morally responsible for the tragedy because they didn't inspect the production facility for safety and were indifferent to everything. The families considered the company to be outright consequentialists worried about keeping their supply lines running, whatever the cost. (b) Ethically analyze the company's position on paying damages and justify why/ why not the company should be liable for damages. (120 words) 10 marks
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
Analysis of company's position 1. Deontological ethics: duty to supply safe medicines. This duty comes from the promise made to consumers of the medicine, and is irrespective of whether the manufacturing is done by the company itself, or sub-contracted out. As a function of this duty, it is the company's responsibility to ensure safety at its contractor's premises, and thus, it is liable to pay damages. 2. Utilitarian ethics: maximum benefit to maximum number of people. If the company escapes liability, other "big pharma" companies will too be encouraged to sub-contract with poor safety. This will lead to compromise in medicine quality, and citizens harmed. Hence, the company is responsible according to utilitarian ethics. 3. Societal ethics and precedents: automobile companies take responsibility for faults in their sub-contractor's practices. (eg) Maruti recalled cars for a fault in airbags, despite it being the fault of the sub-contractor. FMCG companies similarly take responsibility. (eg) Hindustan Unilever for soaps manufactured by a contractor. 4. WD Ross's prima facie principles: principle of promise keeping and principle of non-maleficence, both of which make the company liable.
Thus, based on all ethical theories, and standard industry ethics/business ethics, the company is liable.