Topper Copies

Critics assert that limitless judicial authority rests on the structural ambiguity of the basic structure doctrine. Has the elastic nature of the basic structure doctrine made the judiciary more powerful than the executive?

Ruhani, AIR 5, 2023

Basic structure is a judicial pronouncement of the Keshavananda Bharati case (1973).

It implies that there are certain features in the Constitution which cannot be changed or destroyed through Constitutional amendments.

It is a judicial imagination and is open-ended and ambiguous, thus giving the authority to the judiciary to limit the amending power of the Parliament

Elastic nature of basic structure doctrine This doctrine is elastic as various elements have been added to it through various case laws like: - Keshavananda Bharti case (1973) -> Supremacy of constitution - Indira Gandhi case (1975) -> free and fair elections - Minnerva Mills case (1980) -> Judicial review - Rule of law - Indira Sawhney Case, 1992 - Judicial review - Kihotto Hollohan case, 1993 - Federalism, Secularism, Unity and integrity of India, Social justice - S.R. Bommai Case, 1994 - Equality - Nagaraj Case (2007)

Thus, various case laws have expanded the concept of Basic structure.

Basic structure has made judiciary more powerful than executive

Thus, although the basic structure doctrine is a judicial construct, it has played a seminal role in protecting the Constitution and fundamental rights of citizens.