Topper Copies

You are the Head of an Agency, a special purpose vehicle, responsible for overseeing the last-mile delivery of essential services and sorting out bottlenecks and grievances of the citizens within your jurisdiction. The essential services included Maternal and infant health care, nutritional support to BPL families, drinking water availability, etc. Your agency employed a staff of 15 to carry out regular official operations and handle grievances. Since the agency dealt with complaints, there was an enormous amount of public dealing daily. Sometimes the agency officials had to work beyond office hours to finish the regular office work as public dealings took away most of the office hours. The employees were unhappy doing the extra bit as they were not paid any overtime. A few of them informally raised the issue with you, but you were helpless as the agency rules didn't allow any travel or overtime allowances. You tried taking up the matter with HQ but to no avail. The work stress gradually started showing up among the staff, they became irritable with the complainants, and at times they shouted at them. Besides rudeness, the staff's language became abusive, derogatory, and sometimes casteist. You could notice that there were 4 of them in particular who were getting very abusive and discriminatory while handling grievances. As the Head, you warned them, but there was no marked change in their work attitude. To compound your problem, some of the villagers, through their Sarpanch, raised the issue of rude, disrespectful, and discriminatory behavior with your HQ. The HQ immediately instructed you to take action and create a respectful and dignified workspace. (a) What are the issues involved in the above case? (b) What are the action options available to you? (c) Examine each of the options and identify your chosen course of action. (d) What do you understand by dignity? Distinguish between human and social dignity? Identify the common dignity violations that one notices in government departments. (Answer in 250 words) 20 Marks

Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023

According to research by NITI Aayog, the Indian govt delivers more services per capita population than its level of development/official strength, leading to an overworked bureaucracy.

(a) Issues in the above case 1. Under-staffed bureaucratic agency, against the principle of responsiveness. 2. No extra pay for extra work → against ILO principles of labour dignity. 3. Officials not inspired to go beyond the line of duty → against the principle of "commitment to service". 4. Unresponsive HQ. 5. Abusive/derogatory/casteist comments used → against dignity. 6. Lack of change in attitude/work culture → poor compliance levels in the SPV.

(b) Options available 1. Fire the employees responsible. 2. Motivate and change work culture, apologize to inconvenienced villagers. 3. Ask HQ for extra staff/resources/possibility of outsourcing some functions. 4. Use further innovative methods to reduce burden.

(c) Analysis of options and chosen course of action Option 1: → will lead to further workload, as if the concerned employees are fired, only 11 will be left → this will impact the work of the Agency even more → (ie) against deontological ethics (as duty will be compromised) → it will also lead to poor services for the villagers → (ie) against utilitarian ethics (as the maximum number of people will not be benefitted). Thus, option 1 would be unethical.

Option 2: apologize to inconvenienced villagers, motivate and change work culture. - Part A, apology: will win back trust of citizens → explain to them the issues faced by the Agency → make them participants in governance → move forward with transparency and consensus, by appealing to their empathy. - Part B, use the Aristotelian model of persuasion:

- Ethos: give examples of role models such as Lance Armstrong. - Pathos: appeal to officials' sense of justice. - Logos: warn them of action + convince them of further attempts to reduce stress using technology.

Option 3: Ask HQ for extra staff/outsourcing: Cons: none. Pros: if HQ agrees, work burden will reduce.

Option 4: innovative methods: - Hire some of the villagers → employment to villagers + reduced work load to agency + participatory governance. - Use technology: (eg) ChatGPT based chat bot to resolve grievances → can use Bhashini, the digital India translation tool, for local language.

My chosen course of action: Option 2 + Option 3 + Option 4, parallelly, for transparency, justice, dignity and participation.

(d) Dignity Dignity is simply the inherent worth of every individual.

Social dignity: refers to the respect received/not received in society.

Human dignity: foundational concept → part of Article 21 → by virtue of being born.

All offices must adopt a Citizen's Charter, to ensure no dignity violations in government offices.