You are posted as a District Development officer in a district with a low literacy rate and poor health indicators. As you took charge, your Health Secretary had given express instructions that your priority is to improve health indicators by enhancing the delivery of healthcare services. After taking over, you traveled around the district to study and identify ways of improving healthcare services. During your field trip, you discovered that the issue was not the accessibility of services; it was something else. You found the problem was the myths, misconceptions, and malpractices that hindered the uptake of health care services. For instance, people believed that vaccines caused impotence, immunization was equivalent to birth control, using antenatal care was counterproductive to the health of the mother and baby, and so on. You realize that these beliefs were the behavioral barriers that stood in the way of health and nutrition services. And these behavioral barriers made it difficult for front-line workers to reach out. You discussed your observations with the Health Secretary, and he advised you to seek inputs from the neighboring district DDO who was doing some good work. When you met with the neighboring DDO, you learned he was experimenting with using the Faith leader's influence and reach to persuade people. You were unsure about roping in faith leaders to help you overcome the behavioral barriers. As a civil servant, you felt it would be a mistake to involve faith leaders in health service schemes. When you shared your apprehensions with the Secretary, he firmly instructed you to try and innovate. (a) What are the issues involved in the above case? (b) What are the advantages and disadvantages of using Faith leaders as influencers and persuaders? (c) If not faith leaders, what are your other options for breaking the behavioral barriers? (d) Do you think it is ethically right for a civil servant to involve faith leaders in promoting government schemes? (Answer in 250 words) 20 Marks
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
The given case reminds of government using religious leaders to improve vaccination during COVID-19, or to combat child marriage in states such as Rajasthan.
(a) Issues in the case 1. Presence of fake news.
2. Sleeper effect: cognitive bias leading to acceptance of misinformation. 3. Lack of scientific temper, lack of objectivity, a fundamental value. 4. Difficulty for front-line workers in reaching out → (ie) intolerance in community.
(b) Advantages and disadvantages of using Faith leaders Advantages: 1. Appeal using "ethos" → sort of Aristotelian model of persuasion → citizens will listen to the faith leaders. 2. Messaging via a reliable messenger → Habermas Likelihood Theory of persuasion.
Disadvantages: 1. Against the "logos" principle → also part of the Aristotelian model → no logic in the persuasion → it will not work in the long run. 2. Increasing dependence on faith leaders. 3. Communalisation of secular issues. 4. Influence of faith in development → against development → against utilitarian ethics. 5. Against objectivity, neutrality principles of ethics.
(c) Other options 1. Nobel Prize winning economist Richard Thaler: 4 ways of achieving change in society, all have to work together: education, legislation/schemes, nudge, enforcement. 2. All 4 can be used: - Education: awareness via schools, SHGs, etc. - Legislation/schemes: rule based provisioning of health services. (eg) Mid Day Meal scheme. (eg) Mission Indradhanush. - Nudge: subtle messaging → certain benefits to vaccinated children → monetary benefit (Matru Vandana Yojana) for ante-natal care, etc. - Enforcement: helplines if there is any pressure → police presence to help victims (if society tries to stop progressive individuals). 3. Use of technology: (eg) social media awareness.
(d) Ethicality of involving faith leaders in govt schemes In secular/developmental schemes: No, not ethically right. Reasons explained in the disadvantages section of part (b).
In schemes targeted at particular groups: (eg) Jiyo Parsi scheme, (eg) scheme for social security of pandits/maulanas/etc. Yes, in such schemes it is ethically right, as the purpose of the scheme is linked to faith.