Topper Copies

Civil Services ethics has everything to do with management. It is as much a Departmental as a personal issue. Leaders who fail to create systems that facilitate ethical conduct are equally to blame as much as those who indulge in ethical misconduct. Do you think the Departmental culture leads to ethical misconduct or is the individual with weak willpower culpable? Discuss. (Answer in 150 words) 10 Marks

Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023

Both individual cognitive factors, and organisational normative factors lead to ethical misconduct, though in my opinion, the biggest is the individual factor.

Why is the individual with weak willpower most culpable 1. Setting a bad example for society. 2. Breaking trust vested in him by citizens. 3. Breaking values of transparency, accountability, etc. 4. There are enough examples of people who have not done ethical misconduct even in a poor departmental culture. So a poor dept culture can't always be blamed. (eg) Ashok Khemka, transferred 50+ times. 5. There are grievance redressal mechanisms available. (eg) dept complaint; CPGRAMS complaint; FIR under POCA 1988 Act; etc. 6. Thus, the individual always has a choice.

Organisational culture is also responsible, to some extent 1. Poor incentives to act fairly. 2. Often punishes the honest. (eg) HC Gupta, punished in the coal scam, yet defended by all, across governments.

Thus, we must find a proper way to build strong individual ethics, as "sheelam paranam bhooshanam" represents.