Does the suffering of individuals in one part of the world generate moral demands of assistance on those foreigners who live far away from them? Are these moral demands of assistance justified? Can governments be held morally responsible for failing to help the international community in times of deprivation? Discuss. (Answer in 150 words) 10 Marks
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
The world is interconnected, and suffering anywhere, not just to humans but also to environment, ultimately translates to suffering elsewhere.
This is the essence of James Lovelock's Gaia Hypothesis, that propounds the scientific theory that the world owes as much to cooperation, as to competition.
In this context, yes, it does generate moral demands.
Hence this is evidenced by all countries contributing to aid during times of disaster. (eg) India's Operation Dost in the Turkey earthquake. (eg) Aid received by India during the COVID pandemic wave-II.
Are moral demands of assistance justified? Yes, if the demand is being made of people who can aid without any noticeable harm/ill-effect on themselves. (eg) during COVID-wave II, a moral demand may be made of a nation that is not facing a COVID wave, but not of a nation that itself is under stress.
Moral responsibility of governments for failing to help In some cases yes, in some cases no.
Yes: 1. When they have made a promise. (eg) climate finance. 2. When they are responsible for the crisis. (eg) ethnic violence due to colonialism in Africa.
No: when they are unrelated, and diverting resources may hurt them too. (eg) during ongoing global inflation, the USA/Europe can't divert any resources, as they themselves are suffering from 9%+ inflation.
Hence, a nuanced view is needed in international ethics.