Topper Copies

"While competence without compassion can be brutal and inhumane; similarly, compassion without competence can be meaningless for persons seeking help." Explain the above with the help of a suitable illustration in the context of public services. (Answer in 150 words) 10 Marks

Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023

It is competence and compassion that together make a Karmayogi.

| | Low competence | High competence | |---|---|---| | High compassion | Less efficient in work. Hypothetical example: feeling bad for beggars, but unable to do anything | Efficiency + ethicality. (eg) E Sreedharan, Metro Man, went to court to represent a worker many levels below him | | Low compassion | Corruption. (eg) IRFC CMD | Efficiency, but without concern for the poor. (eg) deforestation affecting forest dwellers |

Competence without compassion 1. Efficiency at the cost of the humane aspect. 2. (ie) technical efficiency, but no social efficiency. (eg) developmental projects related to deforestation that compromise on the rights of vanvasis. According to the Xaxa committee, more than 50% of forest dwellers in India are displaced.

Compassion, without competence 1. Desire to help, but failure to do so because of incompetency → due to lack of skills. 2. Incompetency may be → due to lack of resources. (eg) police often fail in proving/losing cases, due to lack of forensics. (ie) compassion, but no forensic resource competency.

Compassion and competency Metro Man is a great example of the same (E Sreedharan) → desire to help via Public Transport → efficiency of project implementation.

Thus, public servants must take valuable lessons from the experiences of past civil servants.